# # WLUP STANDARD BENCHMARK SEQUENCE # -------------------------------- # # Uranium criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------ SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrume.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== aecl_um 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00042(0.04) 0.701 0.0656 0.1400 1.102 aere_uma1 1.00000(~.80) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01119(1.10) 2.357 0.2023 0.2037 1.508 aere_uma2 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00871(0.86) 2.033 0.1848 0.2017 1.382 aere_uma3 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99482(-.52) 1.291 0.1170 0.1593 1.097 aere_uma4 1.00000(~.27) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99436(-.57) 0.970 0.0880 0.1367 0.964 aere_uma5 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00726(0.72) 0.984 0.0897 0.1378 0.970 hw_uma1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99801(-.20) 1.488 0.1371 0.1736 1.147 hw_uma2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99555(-.45) 1.240 0.1144 0.1582 1.050 hw_uma3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99814(-.19) 1.070 0.0989 0.1468 0.982 hw_uma4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99327(-.68) 0.848 0.0784 0.1315 0.890 hw_umb1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99553(-.45) 1.498 0.1306 0.1551 1.089 hw_umb2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99475(-.53) 1.085 0.0944 0.1287 0.934 hw_umb3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00162(0.16) 0.990 0.0861 0.1219 0.896 hw_umb4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00040(0.04) 2.075 0.1935 0.2069 1.284 hw_umb5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99654(-.35) 1.364 0.1282 0.1694 1.036 hw_umb6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99120(-.89) 1.031 0.0971 0.1494 0.911 bnl_uma1 1.00000(~.16) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99029(-.98) 1.433 0.0984 0.1124 1.069 bnl_uma2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99180(-.83) 1.017 0.0670 0.0856 0.906 bnl_uma3 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99348(-.66) 0.804 0.0518 0.0709 0.819 bnl_uma4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99307(-.70) 1.687 0.1273 0.1393 1.158 bnl_uma5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98941(-1.1) 0.914 0.0659 0.0894 0.862 bnl_uma6 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99485(-.52) 2.266 0.1867 0.1822 1.352 bnl_uma7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98707(-1.3) 0.651 0.0515 0.0824 0.754 bnl_umb1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99057(-.96) 1.859 0.1319 0.1357 1.214 bnl_umb2 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99373(-.63) 1.444 0.0991 0.1120 1.062 bnl_umb3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99307(-.70) 1.025 0.0675 0.0853 0.899 bnl_umb4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99222(-.79) 0.810 0.0522 0.0708 0.813 bnl_umb5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99629(-.37) 1.699 0.1282 0.1387 1.151 bnl_umb6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99321(-.69) 1.309 0.0967 0.1152 1.007 bnl_umb7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99316(-.69) 0.920 0.0663 0.0890 0.855 bnl_umb8 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99023(-.99) 0.725 0.0517 0.0751 0.776 bnl_umb9 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99783(-.22) 2.284 0.1881 0.1815 1.344 bnl_umb10 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99152(-.86) 1.180 0.0945 0.1194 0.954 bnl_umb11 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99100(-.91) 0.828 0.0657 0.0947 0.817 bnl_umb12 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99101(-.91) 0.655 0.0518 0.0821 0.747 bnl_umb13 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99340(-.67) 1.636 0.1377 0.1544 1.119 bnl_umb14 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99224(-.79) 0.977 0.0814 0.1124 0.875 bnl_umb15 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98878(-1.1) 0.828 0.0689 0.1019 0.817 bnl_umb16 1.00000(~.16) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98674(-1.4) 0.650 0.0541 0.0891 0.746 aere_umb1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99775(-.23) 1.501 0.1342 0.1522 0.959 aere_umb2 1.00000(~.25) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99859(-.14) 1.123 0.1006 0.1301 0.836 bnl_umc1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98915(-1.1) 0.872 0.0560 0.0688 0.752 bnl_umc2 1.00000(~.21) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99507(-.50) 1.669 0.1344 0.1390 1.019 bnl_umd1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99524(-.48) 2.034 0.1520 0.1325 1.003 bnl_umd2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99311(-.70) 1.559 0.1142 0.1097 0.869 bnl_umd3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99006(-1.0) 1.089 0.0779 0.0843 0.728 bnl_umd4 1.00000(~.23) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99293(-.71) 1.082 0.0774 0.0838 0.726 bnl_umd5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99031(-.98) 0.853 0.0604 0.0706 0.654 bnl_umd6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99020(-.99) 0.979 0.0768 0.0896 0.692 bnl_umd7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99008(-1.0) 0.771 0.0603 0.0772 0.627 trx_um1 1.00000(~.30) 1.320(~1.6) 0.0987(~1.0) 0.0946(~4.3) 0.797(~1.0) 0.99251(-.76) 1.354(2.58) 0.0981(-.59) 0.0984(4.07) 0.803(0.82) trx_um2 1.00000(~.10) 0.837(~1.9) 0.0614(~1.3) 0.0693(~5.1) 0.647(~.93) 0.99196(-.81) 0.853(1.91) 0.0603(-1.8) 0.0702(1.36) 0.650(0.45) hw_umc1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00015(0.01) 2.030 0.1811 0.1597 0.889 hw_umc2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00272(0.27) 1.694 0.1514 0.1452 0.808 hw_umc3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00328(0.33) 1.450 0.1299 0.1340 0.747 hw_umc4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00539(0.53) 1.137 0.1020 0.1188 0.665 hw_umc5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00448(0.44) 0.946 0.0850 0.1096 0.614 srl_um1 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02213(2.14) 4.275 0.3569 0.1629 0.648 srl_um2 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01064(1.05) 2.998 0.2524 0.1394 0.527 srl_um3 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99754(-.25) 2.403 0.2029 0.1274 0.465 srl_um4 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99865(-.14) 8.256 0.6696 0.2303 0.938 srl_um5 1.00000(~.31) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01312(1.29) 5.215 0.4312 0.1923 0.725 srl_um6 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00098(0.10) 3.924 0.3269 0.1730 0.615 srl_um7 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99274(-.73) 3.192 0.2668 0.1605 0.547 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.24 1.76 1.17 4.71 0.97 -0.39(~0.67) 2.25(~0.34) -1.19(~0.60) 2.71(~1.36) 0.63(~0.18) # # # Uranium UO2 criticality benchmarks # ---------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcruo2.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== bapl1 1.00000(~.10) 1.390(~.72) 0.0840(~2.4) 0.0780(~5.1) 0.000 0.99764(-.24) 1.411(1.52) 0.0830(-1.2) 0.0762(-2.4) 0.817 bapl2 1.00000(~.10) 1.120(~.89) 0.0680(~1.5) 0.0700(~5.7) 0.000 0.99674(-.33) 1.176(5.01) 0.0677(-.49) 0.0657(-6.2) 0.745 bapl3 1.00000(~.10) 0.906(~1.1) 0.0520(~1.9) 0.0570(~5.3) 0.000 0.99646(-.36) 0.926(2.23) 0.0520(0.04) 0.0540(-5.3) 0.667 bapl4 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0710(~9.9) 0.000 0.98968(-1.0) 1.323 0.0787 0.0749(5.54) 0.800 bapl5 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0590(~ 10) 0.000 0.99149(-.86) 1.057 0.0615 0.0625(5.93) 0.717 bapl6 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0510(~7.8) 0.000 0.99025(-.99) 0.884 0.0507 0.0542(6.20) 0.662 naig_nca 1.00000(~.40) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00194(0.19) 1.061 0.0584 0.0427 0.464 curl_zpr1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00338(0.34) 2.472 0.1575 0.0899 0.712 curl_zpr2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98456(-1.6) 1.339 0.0820 0.0574 0.507 curl_zpr3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0460(~2.2) 0.000 0.99298(-.71) 0.958 0.0579 0.0448(-2.5) 0.431 curl_zpr4 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99156(-.85) 0.766 0.0461 0.0386 0.393 baw_bay2a 1.00000(~.25) 2.280(~1.3) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01093(1.08) 2.319(1.73) 0.1350 0.0683 0.580 baw_cx10 1.00000(~.13) 1.850(~1.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99145(-.87) 1.800(-2.7) 0.1019 0.0561 0.500 aerl_ocf1 1.00000(~.22) 1.350(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0430(~4.7) 0.000 0.99994(-.01) 1.419(5.10) 0.0785 0.0456(6.02) 0.434 aerl_ocf2 1.00000(~.40) 1.050(~3.8) 0.0000 0.0330(~6.1) 0.000 1.00029(0.03) 1.077(2.58) 0.0584 0.0366( 11) 0.378 jaeritca1 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99127(-.88) 1.957 0.1122 0.0585 0.498 jaeritca2 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98944(-1.1) 1.752 0.0994 0.0535 0.468 jaeritca3 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98561(-1.5) 1.510 0.0846 0.0475 0.431 jaeritca4 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00854(0.84) 2.200 0.1308 0.0652 0.524 jaeritca5 1.00000(~.19) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99424(-.58) 1.848 0.1083 0.0572 0.474 jaeritca6 1.00000(~.23) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99589(-.41) 1.421 0.0820 0.0466 0.410 jaeritca7 1.00000(~.40) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00073(0.07) 1.211 0.0693 0.0412 0.378 wapd_crxa1 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00236(0.23) 3.732 0.2133 0.0838 0.711 wapd_crxa2 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99927(-.07) 3.303 0.1854 0.0764 0.659 wapd_crxa3 1.00000(~.13) 0.000 0.1580(~3.8) 0.0760(~2.6) 0.000 1.00129(0.13) 2.870 0.1579(-.08) 0.0684( -10) 0.604 wapd_crxa4 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0600(~8.3) 0.000 0.99746(-.25) 2.255 0.1201 0.0562(-6.3) 0.522 wapd_crxa5 1.00000(~.15) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.470(~2.1) 0.99111(-.90) 1.974 0.1035 0.0504 0.482(2.60) wapd_crxa6 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00534(0.53) 0.996 0.0492 0.0286 0.336 aeewjuno 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99127(-.88) 1.674 0.0916 0.0445 0.393 r1100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0928(~.97) 0.629(~.72) 1.00064(0.06) 3.981 0.2364 0.0866(-6.6) 0.652(3.75) r2100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99722(-.28) 1.428 0.0774 0.0387 0.356 r3100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.1113(~1.6) 0.725(~1.1) 1.00105(0.10) 5.065 0.3091 0.1026(-7.8) 0.756(4.25) dimp1a 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0962(~3.3) 0.647(~.46) 0.99960(-.04) 3.978 0.2357 0.0864( -10) 0.651(0.62) bnluo2_1 1.00000(~.05) 2.920(~3.1) 0.0000 0.0650(~1.5) 0.000 0.99303(-.70) 2.945(0.85) 0.1687 0.0667(2.65) 0.548 bnluo2_2 1.00000(~.16) 2.410(~1.7) 0.0000 0.0560(~1.8) 0.000 0.98539(-1.5) 2.430(0.85) 0.1368 0.0579(3.32) 0.487 bnluo2_3 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0480(~2.1) 0.000 0.98648(-1.4) 1.950 0.1079 0.0488(1.73) 0.428 bnluo2_4 1.00000(~.16) 1.410(~1.4) 0.0000 0.0370(~1.1) 0.000 0.98786(-1.2) 1.487(5.43) 0.0808 0.0396(7.14) 0.368 bnluo2_5 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0310(~ 19) 0.000 0.98371(-1.7) 1.113 0.0597 0.0320(3.32) 0.317 anl_zpr7a1 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00185(0.18) 8.645 0.5535 0.1429 1.033 anl_zpr7a2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99613(-.39) 4.951 0.2990 0.1016 0.746 anl_zpr7a3 1.00000(~.26) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99154(-.86) 3.931 0.2315 0.0863 0.647 anl_zpr7a4 1.00000(~.10) 4.120(~.73) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99749(-.25) 4.309(4.59) 0.2537 0.0872 0.687 anl_zpr7a5 1.00000(~.26) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98664(-1.4) 2.844 0.1608 0.0670 0.530 npy_nora1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0620(~4.8) 0.000 1.00291(0.29) 2.649 0.1556 0.0603(-2.8) 0.449 npy_nora2 1.00000(~.32) 1.524(~1.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00332(0.33) 1.552(1.81) 0.0885 0.0404 0.330 npy_nora3 1.00000(~.26) 1.065(~1.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99798(-.20) 1.119(5.07) 0.0632 0.0321 0.279 wapd_crxb1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0780(~6.4) 0.000 1.00320(0.32) 4.298 0.2384 0.0721(-7.6) 0.565 wapd_crxb2 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.408(~4.9) 0.99686(-.31) 2.529 0.1313 0.0472 0.406(-.59) sckvenus1 1.00000(~.48) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99077(-.94) 3.582 0.1969 0.0611 0.463 sckvenus2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99111(-.90) 1.455 0.0743 0.0296 0.271 baw_bay2b1 1.00000(~.33) 5.080(~6.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98754(-1.3) 4.956(-2.4) 0.2886 0.0803 0.564 baw_bay2b2 1.00000(~.12) 4.120(~7.5) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99148(-.86) 4.186(1.60) 0.2398 0.0709 0.507 wapd_crxc 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.2510(~8.0) 0.0700(~7.1) 0.000 0.99629(-.37) 4.649 0.2517(0.29) 0.0643(-8.2) 0.495 anl_zpr7b1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00166(0.16) 5.699 0.3164 0.0717 0.501 anl_zpr7b2 1.00000(~.53) 0.000 0.2430(~ 21) 0.0650(~9.2) 0.000 1.00176(0.17) 4.371 0.2361(-2.8) 0.0588(-9.6) 0.424 wapd_crxd1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00063(0.06) 4.969 0.2677 0.0576 0.394 wapd_crxd2 1.00000(~.36) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01028(1.01) 3.907 0.2057 0.0477 0.338 wapd_crxd3 1.00000(~.21) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00359(0.36) 1.669 0.0832 0.0245 0.201 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.28 3.05 9.24 6.88 2.47 -0.39(~0.66) 2.22(~2.47) -0.72(~1.07) -1.43(~6.41) 2.13(~1.84) # # # WWER criticality benchmarks # --------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : wwercr.ref Compared file : jef22gx.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== p2w1b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98616(-1.4) 1.474 0.0807 0.0627 0.694 p2w1b4t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98434(-1.6) 1.565 0.0859 0.0654 0.718 p3w1b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99491(-.51) 0.952 0.0493 0.0430 0.560 p2w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99915(-.09) 2.913 0.1558 0.0550 0.454 p2w2b0t2 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99458(-.55) 3.006 0.1607 0.0563 0.467 p2w2b0t3 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99313(-.69) 3.130 0.1677 0.0581 0.482 p2w2b5t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00436(0.43) 3.145 0.1686 0.0576 0.477 p2w2b5t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99966(-.03) 3.238 0.1735 0.0589 0.490 p2w2b5t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99968(-.03) 3.362 0.1805 0.0606 0.504 p2w2b6t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00160(0.16) 3.252 0.1745 0.0589 0.488 p2w2b6t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00305(0.30) 3.343 0.1793 0.0600 0.500 p2w2b6t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99995(-.01) 3.469 0.1864 0.0617 0.515 p2w2b7t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00491(0.49) 3.333 0.1790 0.0598 0.495 p1w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98976(-1.0) 5.147 0.2974 0.0855 0.648 p1w2b0t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98195(-1.9) 5.335 0.3078 0.0875 0.667 p1w2b0t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.97899(-2.2) 5.582 0.3223 0.0902 0.688 p1w2b2t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99454(-.55) 5.202 0.3007 0.0858 0.652 p1w2b3t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99208(-.80) 5.230 0.3023 0.0861 0.655 p3w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99804(-.20) 1.815 0.0920 0.0370 0.342 p3w2b5t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00682(0.67) 2.050 0.1042 0.0402 0.368 p4w2b0t1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00205(0.20) 1.070 0.0521 0.0240 0.259 p2w3b0t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99394(-.61) 3.511 0.1862 0.0538 0.416 p2w3b1t1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00084(0.08) 3.546 0.1882 0.0540 0.419 p2w3b7t1 1.00000(~.80) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01210(1.19) 3.947 0.2102 0.0575 0.449 p3w3b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99236(-.77) 2.167 0.1088 0.0361 0.309 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.56 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -0.38(~0.79) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # LWR MOX criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------ SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrmox.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== ge_pu1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00279(0.28) 3.989 0.2328 1.1264 9.219 ge_pu2 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00441(0.44) 2.737 0.1533 0.8505 7.310 ge_pu3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00797(0.79) 1.570 0.0838 0.5452 5.293 ge_pu4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00713(0.70) 1.148 0.0601 0.4248 4.504 ge_pu5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00760(0.75) 0.882 0.0457 0.3475 3.989 ge_pu6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00852(0.84) 0.825 0.0426 0.3311 3.877 wcrx_pu1 1.00000(~.34) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00157(0.16) 5.266 0.3163 0.4795 3.331 wcrx_pu2 1.00000(~.27) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99828(-.17) 3.648 0.2125 0.3729 2.654 wcrx_pu3 1.00000(~.31) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00769(0.76) 1.445 0.0788 0.1822 1.541 wcrx_pu4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00631(0.63) 1.182 0.0641 0.1581 1.391 wcrx_pu5 1.00000(~.08) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00047(0.05) 0.779 0.0430 0.1285 1.153 wcrx_pu6 1.00000(~.35) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00076(0.07) 13.388 0.7268 0.9857 5.986 jtca_pu1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99154(-.86) 2.240 0.1025 0.2175 2.002 jtca_pu2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99336(-.67) 1.832 0.0826 0.1840 1.777 jtca_pu3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99665(-.34) 1.326 0.0587 0.1417 1.486 jtca_pu4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99863(-.14) 1.054 0.0463 0.1193 1.325 bnw_pua1 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99635(-.37) 3.842 0.2245 0.3871 2.741 bnw_pua2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01197(1.17) 2.251 0.1272 0.2605 1.975 bnw_pua3 1.00000(~.11) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01401(1.37) 1.600 0.0892 0.2025 1.626 bnw_pua4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01189(1.17) 1.303 0.0723 0.1751 1.459 bnw_pua5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00697(0.69) 0.965 0.0533 0.1443 1.263 bnw_pua6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01402(1.37) 0.928 0.0513 0.1408 1.241 bnw_pua7 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99541(-.46) 0.697 0.0387 0.1232 1.104 bnw_pua8 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98713(-1.3) 0.692 0.0384 0.1231 1.101 bnw_pub1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01207(1.18) 2.142 0.1194 0.2473 1.921 bnw_pub2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01311(1.29) 1.523 0.0837 0.1921 1.584 bnw_pub3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01498(1.46) 1.239 0.0678 0.1659 1.424 bnw_pub4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00816(0.81) 0.919 0.0501 0.1370 1.237 bnw_pub5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01422(1.39) 0.884 0.0482 0.1338 1.216 bnw_puc1 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00262(0.26) 3.499 0.1997 0.3513 2.592 bnw_puc2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00820(0.81) 2.050 0.1133 0.2364 1.873 bnw_puc3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01472(1.44) 1.457 0.0795 0.1833 1.548 bnw_puc4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00984(0.97) 1.188 0.0645 0.1588 1.395 bnw_puc5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99844(-.16) 0.883 0.0478 0.1316 1.215 bnw_puc6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01421(1.39) 0.848 0.0459 0.1281 1.195 bnw_pud1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00385(0.38) 6.384 0.3568 0.5962 3.818 bnw_pud2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01190(1.17) 4.983 0.2741 0.5049 3.271 bnw_pud3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01218(1.20) 3.621 0.1957 0.4044 2.671 bnw_pud4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00876(0.86) 1.330 0.0702 0.2068 1.481 bnw_pud5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99678(-.32) 0.943 0.0500 0.1775 1.255 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.19 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.53(~0.71) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Intermediate spectrum criticality benchmarks # -------------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrisp.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== hiss1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.03135(2.99) 99.999 10.0000 0.0004 0.054 hiss2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99653(-.35) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.32(~1.67) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # BNL-Th2-U3-H2O criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ==================================== Reference file : expbnlh.ref Compared file : jef22gx.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== BNL_THH2O1 1.00000(~.76) 1.380(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99452(-.55) 1.171( -15) 0.5770 0.0168 0.610 BNL_THH2O2 1.00000(~.45) 0.928(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99304(-.70) 0.819( -12) 0.4167 0.0137 0.573 BNL_THH2O3 1.00000(~.65) 0.754(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99569(-.43) 0.656( -13) 0.3394 0.0120 0.554 BNL_THH2O4 1.00000(~.49) 0.607(~4.3) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99717(-.28) 0.513( -15) 0.2695 0.0103 0.536 BNL_THH2O5 1.00000(~.24) 0.435(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99821(-.18) 0.381( -12) 0.2035 0.0084 0.517 BNL_THH2O6 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00029(0.03) 0.279 0.1513 0.0069 0.502 BNL_THH2O7 1.00000(~.06) 0.218(~3.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99938(-.06) 0.192( -12) 0.1057 0.0056 0.489 BNL_THH2O8 1.00000(~.10) 0.170(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99692(-.31) 0.155(-8.8) 0.0862 0.0051 0.483 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.45 3.66 0.00 0.00 0.00 -0.31(~0.23)-12.65(~2.10) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # BNL-Th2-U3-D2O criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ==================================== Reference file : expbnld.ref Compared file : jef22gx.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== BNL-TD2O-1 1.00000(~.22) 5.190(~ 10) 0.0000 0.0117(~6.8) 0.000 1.00387(0.38) 4.289( -17) 1.7769 0.0108(-8.0) 0.815 BNL-TD2O-2 1.00000(~.28) 0.780(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0056(~ 13) 0.000 0.99001(-1.0) 0.767(-1.7) 0.3948 0.0046( -18) 0.565 BNL-TD2O-3 1.00000(~.40) 0.559(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0047(~ 15) 0.000 0.99260(-.75) 0.544(-2.7) 0.2878 0.0039( -17) 0.538 BNL-TD2O-4 1.00000(~.27) 0.297(~3.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98985(-1.0) 0.296(-.20) 0.1629 0.0032 0.503 BNL-TD2O-5 1.00000(~.75) 0.234(~3.4) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99796(-.20) 0.228(-2.6) 0.1269 0.0029 0.493 BNL-TD2O-6 1.00000(~.59) 0.166(~3.6) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99200(-.81) 0.160(-3.6) 0.0899 0.0027 0.483 BNL-TD2O-7 1.00000(~.99) 0.104(~4.8) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01338(1.31) 0.110(6.15) 0.0623 0.0026 0.475 BNL-TD2O-8 1.00000(~.68) 0.089(~5.6) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01575(1.54) 0.078( -12) 0.0438 0.0025 0.470 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.58 5.35 0.00 11.90 0.00 -0.07(~0.97) -4.26(~6.81) 0.00(~0.00) -14.34(~4.52) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Uranium D2O criticality benchmarks # ---------------------------------- D2OSMR - Summarize WLUP D2O Benchmarks ====================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 2 cases : e1t1.lis 2 cases : e1t2.lis 1 case : e1t3.lis 4 cases : e1t4.lis 6 cases : e2t1.lis LATTICE K-eff Del ConvR CuA LuR =========================================================================== ZED2T1D2O 1.00000(0.00) 0.0511( 1.5) 1.4138( 0.3) 1.140(1.00) 1.206(0.40) 1.00717(0.71) 0.0518( 1.3) 1.4171( 0.2) 1.146(0.82) 1.197(-.75) ZED2T1Air 1.00000(0.00) 0.0583( 1.5) 1.3765( 0.3) 1.146(1.00) 1.223(0.40) 1.01125(1.11) 0.0592( 1.5) 1.3676(-0.6) 1.147(0.65) 1.217(-.53) ZED2T2p24 1.00000(0.00) 0.0580( 1.5) 0.9258( 0.6) 0.99916(-.08) 0.0527(-9.2) 0.9082(-1.9) ZED2T2p40 1.00000(0.00) 0.0547( 1.5) 0.7663( 0.6) 1.00625(0.62) 0.0484(****) 0.7379(-3.7) ZED2T3p24 1.00000(0.00) 1.00462(0.46) ZED2T4D22 1.00000(0.00) 0.0071(10.0) 0.99793(-.21) 0.0079(11.2) ZED2T4A22 1.00000(0.00) 0.0069(10.0) 1.00173(0.17) 0.0089(28.1) ZED2T4D28 1.00000(0.00) 0.0061(10.0) 0.99680(-.32) 0.0076(24.7) ZED2T4A28 1.00000(0.00) 0.0069(10.0) 0.99844(-.16) 0.0086(24.4) DCAT1D22 1.00000(0.00) 1.00104(0.10) DCAT1A22 1.00000(0.00) 1.00055(0.06) DCAT1H22 1.00000(0.00) 1.00130(0.13) DCAT1D25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00129(0.13) DCAT1A25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00144(0.14) DCAT1H25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00179(0.18) =========================================================================== Average (0.00) ( 5.8) ( 0.5) (1.00) (0.40) Dif/St.Dv 0.20(0.42) 8.8(17.1) -1.5( 2.1) 0.73(0.74) -0.64(0.65) # # # IRPhE D2O criticality benchmarks # -------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : critd2o.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== minor1 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98802(-1.2) 1.001 0.0927 0.0755 1.259 minor1 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99250(-.76) 0.623 0.0575 0.0657 1.046 minor1 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99455(-.55) 0.436 0.0401 0.0613 0.936 minor1 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99836(-.16) 0.328 0.0300 0.0590 0.872 minor1 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99796(-.20) 0.262 0.0237 0.0579 0.832 minor1 6 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99764(-.24) 0.218 0.0194 0.0574 0.805 minor1 7 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99887(-.11) 0.152 0.0128 0.0568 0.765 minor2 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99026(-.99) 0.585 0.0507 0.0526 1.025 minor2 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99209(-.80) 0.463 0.0401 0.0496 0.952 minor2 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99330(-.68) 0.378 0.0327 0.0477 0.902 minor2 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99593(-.41) 0.316 0.0273 0.0463 0.864 minor2 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99609(-.39) 0.270 0.0233 0.0455 0.836 minor2 6 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99655(-.35) 0.206 0.0177 0.0444 0.797 minor2 7 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99541(-.46) 0.166 0.0141 0.0440 0.772 minor3 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99088(-.92) 0.586 0.0508 0.0526 1.025 minor3 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99704(-.30) 0.270 0.0233 0.0455 0.836 minor4 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99545(-.46) 0.406 0.0387 0.0746 0.920 minor4 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99763(-.24) 0.334 0.0314 0.0733 0.877 minor4 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99732(-.27) 0.286 0.0263 0.0727 0.848 minor4 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99462(-.54) 0.253 0.0228 0.0725 0.828 minor4 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99859(-.14) 0.228 0.0202 0.0720 0.814 srlur 7 1.00000(~.45) 0.181 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00090(0.09) 0.225( 24) 0.0201 0.0542(6.25) 0.810 srlur 8 1.00000(~.50) 0.132 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00257(0.26) 0.181( 37) 0.0159 0.0536(5.16) 0.783 srlur 9 1.00000(~.65) 0.114 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00573(0.57) 0.151( 32) 0.0128 0.0533(4.45) 0.765 srlur 12 1.00000(~.85) 0.086 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00990(0.98) 0.120( 40) 0.0097 0.0531(4.02) 0.746 norahw s1 1.00000(~.44) 0.374(~6.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99962(-.04) 0.366(-2.1) 0.0196 0.0114 0.208 norahw s2 1.00000(~.56) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02700(2.59) 0.779 0.0411 0.0124 0.268 norahw s3 1.00000(~.45) 1.540(~2.9) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02247(2.17) 1.355( -12) 0.0717 0.0148 0.347 norahw s4 1.00000(~.23) 2.570(~2.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99804(-.20) 2.488(-3.2) 0.1342 0.0200 0.493 norahw s6 1.00000(~.72) 3.480(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00769(0.76) 3.145(-9.6) 0.1720 0.0229 0.571 wlrx 65x65 1.00000(~.20) 0.740(~5.4) 0.0535(~.37) 0.0453(~.44) 0.000 0.99383(-.62) 0.855( 16) 0.0542(1.29) 0.0317( -30) 0.770 wlrx 65x80 1.00000(~.30) 0.671(~1.5) 0.0000 0.0483(~2.9) 0.000 1.00676(0.67) 0.676(0.75) 0.0428 0.0300( -38) 0.701 wlrx 80x80 1.00000(~.45) 0.493(~.61) 0.0450(~2.2) 0.0356(~.56) 0.000 1.01351(1.32) 0.546( 11) 0.0345( -23) 0.0289( -19) 0.650 dimpsghw1 1.00000(~.46) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00781(0.77) 1.625 0.1205 0.0555 1.005 dimpsghw2 1.00000(~.37) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01674(1.63) 1.501 0.0945 0.0393 0.974 dimpsghw5 1.00000(~.15) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.03224(3.07) 0.775 0.0426 0.0368 0.712 dimpsghw3 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01423(1.39) 1.242 0.0742 0.0386 0.883 dimpsghw4 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02520(2.43) 1.050 0.0606 0.0375 0.814 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.34 3.05 1.59 3.17 0.00 0.20(~1.05) 12.16(~****) -11.07(~****) -9.58(~****) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Uranium D2O burnup benchmark # ---------------------------- D2OE3B comparison AVERAGE VALUES (Ni/Nj%)(delta%) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E3.lis BUP N25/N28 N26/N28 N49/N28 N40/N49 N41/N49 N42/N4 ============================================================================ EXP 3250 0.438( 2.0) 0.044( 2.0) 0.178( 2.0) 16.50( 2.0) 2.240( 2.0) 0.220( 2.0) 0.436(-0.4) 0.043(-1.3) 0.175(-1.8) 16.91( 2.5) 2.353( 5.1) 0.221( 0.3) EXP 6500 0.247( 2.0) 0.074( 2.0) 0.242( 2.0) 34.30( 2.0) 6.290( 2.0) 1.580( 2.0) 0.260( 5.4) 0.069(-6.2) 0.239(-1.2) 33.48(-2.4) 6.305( 0.2) 1.388(-12.2) EXP 10800 0.122( 2.0) 0.089( 2.0) 0.267( 2.0) 53.60( 2.0)11.140( 2.0) 5.110( 2.0) 0.125( 2.6) 0.089(-0.3) 0.265(-0.7) 54.74( 2.1)11.680( 4.8) 5.057( -1.0) ============================================================================ Average ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) Dif/St.Dv 2.13( 1.6) -3.92( 2.4) -2.43( 2.3) 0.83( 1.8) 3.42( 1.7) -4.38( 4.4) # # # NEA/CRP Burnup Credit Criticality Benchmarks # Part-1A: Criticality prediction # -------------------------------------------- WEDB1A - NEA Burnup Credit Benchmark ==================================== Part-1A Criticality Prediction Calculated results filename: : bucr1a.OUT Delta K = K(Case n) - K(Case 1) Second row gives: Uncertainty (2 sigma) for reference Difference from reference for cal. Third row gives the same in % CASE K - REF. K - CAL. DELTA K-REF. DELTA K-CAL. 1 1.43780 1.44196 0 0 1750 416 0 0 0.29 0.00 2 1.14020 1.13601 -29760 -30595 1689 -418 1339 -835 -0.37 2.81 3 1.06380 1.05941 -37400 -38255 1700 -439 1539 -855 -0.41 2.29 4 1.24560 1.24524 -19220 -19672 1070 -35 970 -452 -0.03 2.35 5 1.18850 1.18730 -24930 -25466 1099 -119 1070 -536 -0.10 2.15 6 1.11230 1.10817 -32550 -33378 1640 -412 1489 -828 -0.37 2.55 7 1.02400 1.01949 -41380 -42247 1559 -451 1470 -867 -0.44 2.10 8 1.22840 1.22827 -20939 -21369 1090 -13 989 -429 -0.01 2.05 9 1.16570 1.16399 -27210 -27797 989 -170 1140 -587 -0.15 2.16 10 1.26350 1.26354 -17430 -17842 1080 3 999 -412 0.00 2.37 11 1.25660 1.25664 -18119 -18532 1090 4 970 -412 0.00 2.27 # # # NEA/CRP Burnup Credit Criticality Benchmarks # Part-1B: Isotopic composition prediction # -------------------------------------------- WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.96975 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.568E-01 -2.0 1.600E-01 0.0 U -235 8.369E+00 -1.2 8.470E+00 0.0 U -236 3.113E+00 -0.9 3.140E+00 0.0 U -238 8.376E+02 -0.6 8.425E+02 0.0 Pu-238 8.889E-02 -12.2 1.012E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.147E+00 -2.7 4.264E+00 0.0 Pu-240 1.678E+00 -2.4 1.719E+00 0.0 Pu-241 6.497E-01 -4.6 6.812E-01 0.0 Pu-242 2.632E-01 -8.8 2.886E-01 0.0 Am-241 2.355E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 3.702E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 2.636E-01 -1.6 2.680E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 5.666E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 5.954E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 5.689E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 3.487E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 4.913E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 8.366E-01 -1.6 8.500E-01 0.0 Cs-135 3.718E-01 3.3 3.600E-01 0.0 Nd-143 6.118E-01 -0.2 6.130E-01 0.0 Nd-145 5.084E-01 -0.3 5.100E-01 0.0 Sm-147 1.897E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 1.828E-03 -37.0 2.900E-03 0.0 Sm-150 1.903E-01 -8.1 2.070E-01 0.0 Sm-151 8.355E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 8.822E-02 1.4 8.700E-02 0.0 Eu-153 8.178E-02 3.5 7.900E-02 0.0 Gd-155 2.222E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 3.463E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | ---+ | U -235 | --+ | U -236 | -+ | U -238 | -+ | Pu-238 | ------------------+ | Pu-239 | ----+ | Pu-240 | ----+ | Pu-241 | -------+ | Pu-242 | -------------+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | --+ | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | --+ | Cs-135 | +----- | Nd-143 | I | Nd-145 | I | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | ------------+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +-- | Eu-153 | +----- | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.96975 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.570E-01 -1.3 1.590E-01 5.2 U -235 8.470E+00 3.4 8.190E+00 3.0 U -236 3.101E+00 -3.8 3.224E+00 2.9 U -238 8.376E+02 0.0 8.375E+02 0.1 Pu-238 8.961E-02 -5.7 9.504E-02 8.5 Pu-239 4.262E+00 0.8 4.230E+00 5.2 Pu-240 1.689E+00 -1.2 1.710E+00 4.0 Pu-241 6.657E-01 -0.6 6.697E-01 6.4 Pu-242 2.650E-01 -4.0 2.761E-01 8.7 Am-241 2.355E-01 -2.9 2.426E-01 4.2 Am-243 3.702E-02 -9.7 4.101E-02 11.3 Np-237 2.660E-01 -8.6 2.912E-01 8.6 Mo- 95 5.666E-01 0.0 5.666E-01 1.2 Tc- 99 5.954E-01 -0.5 5.985E-01 5.2 Ru-101 5.689E-01 0.9 5.637E-01 1.0 Rh-103 3.487E-01 -0.1 3.492E-01 4.6 Ag-109 4.913E-02 -16.6 5.892E-02 7.1 Cs-133 8.366E-01 -0.6 8.415E-01 4.9 Cs-135 3.718E-01 -2.7 3.821E-01 2.9 Nd-143 6.136E-01 -1.5 6.232E-01 2.8 Nd-145 5.079E-01 0.3 5.066E-01 1.0 Sm-147 1.897E-01 5.1 1.806E-01 6.0 Sm-149 1.862E-03 -9.4 2.054E-03 14.1 Sm-150 1.907E-01 -2.4 1.953E-01 5.3 Sm-151 8.355E-03 -14.2 9.742E-03 22.4 Sm-152 8.813E-02 -6.2 9.394E-02 7.2 Eu-153 8.219E-02 7.4 7.655E-02 7.9 Gd-155 2.222E-03 -42.7 3.879E-03 33.5 Gd-157 3.463E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | X --+ | U -235 | +---X- | U -236 | --X---+ | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | X ---------+ | Pu-239 | +- X | Pu-240 | X --+ | Pu-241 | X -+ | Pu-242 | X ------+ | Am-241 | X ----+ | Am-243 | X ---------------+ | Np-237 | X------------+ | Mo- 95 | X I | Tc- 99 | X -+ | Ru-101 | +-X | Rh-103 | X I | Ag-109 | --------------X----------+ | Cs-133 | X -+ | Cs-135 | X---+ | Nd-143 | X --+ | Nd-145 | I X | Sm-147 | +--------X | Sm-149 | X --------------+ | Sm-150 | X ----+ | Sm-151 | ---------------------+ | Sm-152 | X ---------+ | Eu-153 | +-----------X | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.88341 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.342E-01 -4.1 1.400E-01 0.0 U -235 4.986E+00 -3.5 5.170E+00 0.0 U -236 3.538E+00 0.2 3.530E+00 0.0 U -238 8.305E+02 -0.3 8.327E+02 0.0 Pu-238 1.692E-01 -10.6 1.893E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.228E+00 -3.0 4.357E+00 0.0 Pu-240 2.186E+00 -2.4 2.239E+00 0.0 Pu-241 8.573E-01 -5.0 9.028E-01 0.0 Pu-242 5.382E-01 -6.6 5.761E-01 0.0 Am-241 3.028E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 1.024E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 3.743E-01 5.1 3.560E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 7.331E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 7.787E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 7.691E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 4.439E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 7.628E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 1.083E+00 -0.6 1.090E+00 0.0 Cs-135 4.024E-01 0.6 4.000E-01 0.0 Nd-143 7.123E-01 -0.5 7.160E-01 0.0 Nd-145 6.478E-01 -0.8 6.530E-01 0.0 Sm-147 2.142E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 1.984E-03 -33.9 3.000E-03 0.0 Sm-150 2.682E-01 -1.0 2.710E-01 0.0 Sm-151 9.257E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 1.109E-01 6.6 1.040E-01 0.0 Eu-153 1.233E-01 13.1 1.090E-01 0.0 Gd-155 3.687E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 3.735E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | ------+ | U -235 | -----+ | U -236 | I | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | ----------------+ | Pu-239 | ----+ | Pu-240 | ----+ | Pu-241 | --------+ | Pu-242 | ----------+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | +-------- | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | -+ | Cs-135 | +- | Nd-143 | -+ | Nd-145 | -+ | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | --+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +---------- | Eu-153 | +-------------------- | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.88341 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.346E-01 -1.2 1.363E-01 7.1 U -235 5.088E+00 4.3 4.879E+00 6.0 U -236 3.524E+00 -3.0 3.633E+00 2.8 U -238 8.305E+02 0.0 8.304E+02 0.2 Pu-238 1.704E-01 -7.1 1.835E-01 7.5 Pu-239 4.332E+00 0.4 4.314E+00 6.1 Pu-240 2.197E+00 0.3 2.189E+00 4.3 Pu-241 8.766E-01 -1.0 8.859E-01 6.0 Pu-242 5.392E-01 -3.6 5.593E-01 8.3 Am-241 3.028E-01 -2.9 3.119E-01 4.3 Am-243 1.024E-01 -9.9 1.137E-01 10.4 Np-237 3.773E-01 -9.8 4.183E-01 8.9 Mo- 95 7.331E-01 0.0 7.333E-01 1.3 Tc- 99 7.787E-01 0.5 7.745E-01 3.6 Ru-101 7.691E-01 1.1 7.611E-01 1.0 Rh-103 4.439E-01 0.1 4.436E-01 5.2 Ag-109 7.628E-02 -11.0 8.570E-02 7.0 Cs-133 1.084E+00 -0.1 1.085E+00 4.9 Cs-135 4.024E-01 -3.0 4.148E-01 3.2 Nd-143 7.158E-01 -1.8 7.292E-01 3.9 Nd-145 6.478E-01 0.4 6.454E-01 1.3 Sm-147 2.142E-01 6.6 2.010E-01 7.9 Sm-149 2.016E-03 -8.7 2.208E-03 15.0 Sm-150 2.682E-01 -2.1 2.738E-01 7.1 Sm-151 9.257E-03 -15.2 1.092E-02 21.7 Sm-152 1.107E-01 -7.4 1.195E-01 9.0 Eu-153 1.238E-01 8.7 1.139E-01 8.2 Gd-155 3.687E-03 -44.8 6.676E-03 33.3 Gd-157 3.735E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | X --+ | U -235 | +------ X | U -236 | -X---+ | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | X----------+ | Pu-239 | +- X | Pu-240 | +- X | Pu-241 | X --+ | Pu-242 | X -----+ | Am-241 | X ----+ | Am-243 | X---------------+ | Np-237 | --X------------+ | Mo- 95 | X I | Tc- 99 | +- X | Ru-101 | +-X | Rh-103 | I X | Ag-109 | ------X---------+ | Cs-133 | X I | Cs-135 | X----+ | Nd-143 | X ---+ | Nd-145 | +-X | Sm-147 | +---------- X | Sm-149 | X -------------+ | Sm-150 | X ---+ | Sm-151 | -----------------------+ | Sm-152 | X -----------+ | Eu-153 | +-----------X- | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.83000 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.197E-01 -0.2 1.200E-01 0.0 U -235 3.384E+00 -4.4 3.540E+00 0.0 U -236 3.689E+00 0.0 3.690E+00 0.0 U -238 8.249E+02 0.0 8.249E+02 0.0 Pu-238 2.411E-01 -10.3 2.688E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.323E+00 -0.8 4.357E+00 0.0 Pu-240 2.478E+00 -2.5 2.543E+00 0.0 Pu-241 9.809E-01 -3.8 1.020E+00 0.0 Pu-242 7.746E-01 -7.8 8.401E-01 0.0 Am-241 3.305E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 1.740E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 4.520E-01 -3.4 4.680E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 8.453E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 9.034E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 9.143E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 5.002E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 9.680E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 1.246E+00 0.5 1.240E+00 0.0 Cs-135 4.171E-01 -3.0 4.300E-01 0.0 Nd-143 7.602E-01 -0.4 7.630E-01 0.0 Nd-145 7.370E-01 -0.9 7.440E-01 0.0 Sm-147 2.224E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 2.163E-03 -54.0 4.700E-03 0.0 Sm-150 3.260E-01 -9.7 3.610E-01 0.0 Sm-151 9.898E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 1.248E-01 3.1 1.210E-01 0.0 Eu-153 1.534E-01 3.6 1.480E-01 0.0 Gd-155 4.865E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 3.861E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | I | U -235 | -------+ | U -236 | I | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | ---------------+ | Pu-239 | -+ | Pu-240 | ----+ | Pu-241 | ------+ | Pu-242 | ------------+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | -----+ | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | +- | Cs-135 | ----+ | Nd-143 | -+ | Nd-145 | -+ | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | ---------------+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +----- | Eu-153 | +----- | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.83000 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.203E-01 -1.0 1.215E-01 9.0 U -235 3.350E+00 4.7 3.201E+00 8.1 U -236 3.682E+00 -2.3 3.769E+00 2.6 U -238 8.249E+02 -0.3 8.274E+02 0.2 Pu-238 2.376E-01 -7.6 2.572E-01 6.6 Pu-239 4.297E+00 -0.1 4.303E+00 7.1 Pu-240 2.471E+00 1.4 2.437E+00 5.3 Pu-241 9.770E-01 -1.2 9.892E-01 6.9 Pu-242 7.801E-01 -2.3 7.985E-01 8.4 Am-241 3.305E-01 -2.9 3.403E-01 5.3 Am-243 1.740E-01 -9.2 1.917E-01 10.4 Np-237 4.493E-01 -10.2 5.005E-01 9.4 Mo- 95 8.453E-01 0.2 8.440E-01 1.9 Tc- 99 9.034E-01 0.9 8.958E-01 4.2 Ru-101 9.143E-01 1.3 9.021E-01 1.8 Rh-103 5.002E-01 0.3 4.989E-01 5.4 Ag-109 9.680E-02 -8.1 1.053E-01 7.6 Cs-133 1.248E+00 0.4 1.244E+00 5.6 Cs-135 4.171E-01 -3.4 4.318E-01 4.4 Nd-143 7.579E-01 -2.2 7.748E-01 4.5 Nd-145 7.377E-01 0.5 7.339E-01 1.5 Sm-147 2.224E-01 7.5 2.070E-01 9.1 Sm-149 2.140E-03 -8.4 2.336E-03 15.6 Sm-150 3.250E-01 -1.8 3.311E-01 8.5 Sm-151 9.898E-03 -15.5 1.171E-02 22.3 Sm-152 1.251E-01 -7.7 1.355E-01 9.7 Eu-153 1.535E-01 9.9 1.397E-01 8.5 Gd-155 4.865E-03 -45.0 8.849E-03 33.0 Gd-157 3.861E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | X -+ | U -235 | +------- X | U -236 | X---+ | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | -X---------+ | Pu-239 | X I | Pu-240 | +-- X | Pu-241 | X --+ | Pu-242 | X ---+ | Am-241 | X ----+ | Am-243 | X --------------+ | Np-237 | -X-------------+ | Mo- 95 | I X | Tc- 99 | +- X | Ru-101 | +--X | Rh-103 | I X | Ag-109 | -X----------+ | Cs-133 | +- X | Cs-135 | X -----+ | Nd-143 | X ---+ | Nd-145 | +-X | Sm-147 | +----------- X | Sm-149 | X -------------+ | Sm-150 | X ---+ | Sm-151 | -----------------------+ | Sm-152 | X -----------+ | Eu-153 | +------------X-- | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # # # NEA/CRP Plutonium Recycling Benchmarks # -------------------------------------- WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark A - Highly degraded Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.94878 ************************ Calculated results : purecya.OUT Reference results : purecya.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 8.208E-02 1.4 8.095E-02 3.0 U -235 3.085E+00 3.1 2.991E+00 1.0 U -236 5.385E-01 -6.3 5.746E-01 3.2 U -238 7.403E+02 0.1 7.397E+02 0.1 Np-237 2.009E-01 2.9 1.952E-01 9.5 Pu-238 3.601E+00 3.3 3.485E+00 4.7 Pu-239 2.530E+01 2.2 2.475E+01 1.2 Pu-240 2.408E+01 -0.9 2.431E+01 3.2 Pu-241 1.333E+01 2.1 1.306E+01 3.4 Pu-242 2.069E+01 2.9 2.010E+01 8.2 Am-241 1.287E+00 1.4 1.269E+00 3.9 Am-242m 3.352E-02 4.7 3.202E-02 16.9 Am-243 3.136E+00 -14.7 3.677E+00 25.6 Cm-242 2.037E-01 -0.3 2.043E-01 5.3 Cm-243 7.880E-03 -3.3 8.149E-03 7.3 Cm-244 1.629E+00 -0.5 1.637E+00 3.8 Mo- 95 7.774E-01 2.9 7.557E-01 8.0 Tc- 99 1.006E+00 1.0 9.956E-01 5.9 Ru-101 1.085E+00 0.8 1.077E+00 2.1 Rh-103 9.479E-01 -1.5 9.619E-01 4.5 Pd-105 9.886E-01 0.8 9.811E-01 2.5 Pd-107 6.471E-01 -5.1 6.822E-01 1.4 Pd-108 4.771E-01 -2.9 4.914E-01 3.3 Ag-109 2.397E-01 4.4 2.295E-01 18.7 Xe-131 6.156E-01 2.7 5.994E-01 6.9 Xe-135 5.045E-04 -0.4 5.065E-04 2.8 Cs-133 1.436E+00 0.7 1.426E+00 5.3 Cs-135 1.230E+00 -2.4 1.260E+00 1.7 Nd-143 1.087E+00 -6.7 1.165E+00 13.7 Nd-145 7.764E-01 -3.3 8.026E-01 5.7 Pm-147 2.168E-01 12.2 1.932E-01 29.3 Pm-148m 4.059E-03 3.3 3.928E-03 12.6 Sm-149 1.215E-02 -9.5 1.343E-02 18.6 Sm-150 3.718E-01 -3.9 3.869E-01 7.3 Sm-151 5.944E-02 -11.1 6.683E-02 31.4 Sm-152 1.759E-01 -3.2 1.817E-01 15.8 Eu-153 2.076E-01 7.7 1.927E-01 11.5 Eu-154 7.335E-02 2.3 7.170E-02 16.8 Eu-155 2.931E-02 34.7 2.176E-02 40.2 O - 16 1.184E+02 0.0 1.184E+02 0.0 # ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark A - Highly degraded Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : purecya.OUT Reference results : purecya.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +-- X | U -235 | +-X--- | U -236 | ----X----+ | U -238 | I | Np-237 | +---- X | Pu-238 | +----- X | Pu-239 | +-X- | Pu-240 | X -+ | Pu-241 | +--- X | Pu-242 | +---- X | Am-241 | +-- X | Am-242m| +------- X | Am-243 | ----------------------+ | Cm-242 | X I | Cm-243 | X -----+ | Cm-244 | X -+ | Mo- 95 | +---- X | Tc- 99 | +-- X | Ru-101 | +- X | Rh-103 | X --+ | Pd-105 | +- X | Pd-107 | ------X-+ | Pd-108 | X----+ | Ag-109 | +------- X | Xe-131 | +---- X | Xe-135 | X -+ | Cs-133 | +- X | Cs-135 | -X--+ | Nd-143 | X ----------+ | Nd-145 | X -----+ | Pm-147 | +------------------ | Pm-148m| +----- X | Sm-149 | X --------------+ | Sm-150 | X ------+ | Sm-151 | -----------------+ | Sm-152 | X -----+ | Eu-153 | +------------ X | Eu-154 | +--- X | Eu-155 | +-----------------------------> O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark B - Normal PWR recycled Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.92313 ************************ Calculated results : purecyb.OUT Reference results : purecyb.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 2.147E-02 12.8 1.904E-02 26.3 U -235 8.424E-01 5.5 7.984E-01 1.1 U -236 2.377E-01 -4.9 2.499E-01 2.5 U -238 8.008E+02 0.1 8.000E+02 0.1 Np-237 1.588E-01 7.6 1.476E-01 11.1 Pu-238 8.577E-01 6.5 8.054E-01 10.8 Pu-239 1.263E+01 4.5 1.208E+01 2.5 Pu-240 1.004E+01 0.8 9.957E+00 2.8 Pu-241 6.372E+00 2.1 6.240E+00 1.3 Pu-242 3.732E+00 -4.8 3.921E+00 6.8 Am-241 4.480E-01 3.0 4.351E-01 3.8 Am-242m 9.576E-03 5.5 9.080E-03 20.8 Am-243 1.067E+00 -5.1 1.125E+00 9.0 Cm-242 1.300E-01 -1.5 1.320E-01 6.5 Cm-243 5.061E-03 -8.3 5.519E-03 18.7 Cm-244 7.015E-01 -0.8 7.072E-01 5.6 Mo- 95 7.675E-01 3.9 7.384E-01 6.7 Tc- 99 9.782E-01 0.1 9.775E-01 4.6 Ru-101 1.072E+00 0.4 1.067E+00 1.6 Rh-103 8.187E-01 -3.4 8.478E-01 3.1 Pd-105 9.714E-01 0.4 9.674E-01 1.8 Pd-107 6.297E-01 -6.1 6.705E-01 2.1 Pd-108 4.591E-01 -6.0 4.886E-01 2.0 Ag-109 2.165E-01 1.6 2.130E-01 18.1 Xe-131 5.785E-01 1.7 5.689E-01 6.7 Xe-135 3.131E-04 0.4 3.119E-04 3.2 Cs-133 1.386E+00 -0.5 1.392E+00 4.3 Cs-135 8.690E-01 -1.0 8.780E-01 2.9 Nd-143 9.760E-01 -6.7 1.046E+00 12.7 Nd-145 7.450E-01 -4.0 7.757E-01 5.7 Pm-147 1.945E-01 5.3 1.848E-01 22.2 Pm-148m 2.723E-03 -3.3 2.815E-03 6.5 Sm-149 4.992E-03 -4.2 5.213E-03 12.0 Sm-150 3.905E-01 -3.8 4.057E-01 5.0 Sm-151 3.034E-02 -3.4 3.142E-02 26.5 Sm-152 1.646E-01 -8.4 1.796E-01 15.9 Eu-153 2.164E-01 6.1 2.041E-01 9.5 Eu-154 8.209E-02 7.5 7.634E-02 18.3 Eu-155 2.285E-02 21.8 1.877E-02 27.9 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.1 1.184E+02 0.0 # ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark B - Normal PWR recycled Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : purecyb.OUT Reference results : purecyb.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +------------------- | U -235 | +-X------ | U -236 | ---X---+ | U -238 | I | Np-237 | +----------- X | Pu-238 | +---------- X | Pu-239 | +---X--- | Pu-240 | +- X | Pu-241 | +-X- | Pu-242 | X -------+ | Am-241 | +---- X | Am-242m| +-------- | Am-243 | X --------+ | Cm-242 | X --+ | Cm-243 | X ------------+ | Cm-244 | X -+ | Mo- 95 | +------ X | Tc- 99 | I X | Ru-101 | +-X | Rh-103 | X----+ | Pd-105 | +- X | Pd-107 | ------X--+ | Pd-108 | ------X--+ | Ag-109 | +-- X | Xe-131 | +--- X | Xe-135 | +- X | Cs-133 | X -+ | Cs-135 | X --+ | Nd-143 | X ----------+ | Nd-145 | X ------+ | Pm-147 | +-------- | Pm-148m| X -----+ | Sm-149 | X ------+ | Sm-150 | X------+ | Sm-151 | -----+ | Sm-152 | X -------------+ | Eu-153 | +--------- X | Eu-154 | +----------- X | Eu-155 | +-----------------------------> O - 16 | I | # # # Rowlands PinCell Benchmarks # --------------------------- Rowlands Pin-cell Uranium Benchmark =================================== Case summary ------------ Case Tfuel Tcan Tmod. RhoW B**2 (K) (K) (K) (g/cm3) (1/cm2) 1,5 290 293 293 1.0 0.01 2,6 293 293 293 0.7 0.01 3,7 900 600 550 0.7 0.01 4,8 550 550 550 0.7 0.01 NOTE: - Reference results contain the uncertainty in braces [pcm] - WIMS results contain the difference from reference in braces [pcm] Multiplication factors K-inf ---------------------------- Case 1 2 3 4 Ref. 1.38796( 82) 1.33613( 107) 1.30385( 127) 1.31843( 168) WIMS 1.38579(-217) 1.33487(-126) 1.30181(-205) 1.31701(-142) Multiplication factors K-eff ---------------------------- Case 5 6 7 8 Ref. 0.99676( 356) 0.81517( 370) 0.79301( 378) 0.80113( 201) WIMS 0.99736( 60) 0.81886( 369) 0.79537( 236) 0.80419( 306) Change in K-inf due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 1-2 2-4 4-3 2-3 1-3 Ref. 5183( 49) 1771( 97) 1458( 92) 3229( 39) 8411( 50) WIMS 5092( -91) 1786( 15) 1520( 62) 3306( 77) 8398( -13) Change in K-inf due to leakage [pcm] ------------------------------------ Case 1-5 2-6 3-7 4-8 Ref. 39120( 85) 52097( 213) 51084( 219) 51729( 232) WIMS 38843(-277) 51601(-496) 50643(-441) 51282(-447) Change in K-eff due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 5-6 6-8 8-7 6-7 Ref. 18160( 174) 1403( 9) 813( 20) 2216( 24) WIMS 17850(-310) 1448( 45) 861( 48) 2309( 93) Rowlands Plutonium Pin-cell Benchmark ===================================== Case summary ------------ Case Material Tfuel Tcan Tmod (K) (K) (K) 1 MOX-1 300 300 300 2 MOX-1 560 300 300 3 MOX-2 560 300 300 4 MOX-2 300 300 300 NOTE: - Reference results contain the uncertainty in braces [pcm] - WIMS results contain the difference from reference in braces [pcm] Multiplication factors K-inf ---------------------------- Case 1 2 3 4 Ref. 1.21951( 133) 1.20507( 143) 1.24911( 79) 1.26246( 152) WIMS 1.21916( -35) 1.20411( -96) 1.24690(-221) 1.26142(-104) Change in K-inf due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 1-2 4-3 Ref. 1444( 40) 1335( 64) WIMS 1505( 61) 1451( 116) # # # WLUP SUPPLEMENTARY BENCHMARK SEQUENCE # ------------------------------------- # # U-H2O-Be criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : bermar.ref Compared file : jef22gx.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== ber-tubes 1.68681(~.03) 8.545(~.11) 0.0528(~.19) 0.0001 0.011 1.57721(-4.3) 7.561( -12) 0.0541(2.42) 0.0001( 30) 0.010( -11) ber-hom 1.00036(~.06) 13.150(~.01) 0.0699(~.14) 0.0001 0.016 0.92338(-8.7) 13.215(0.49) 0.0662(-5.3) 0.0001( -10) 0.016(2.50) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.05 0.07 0.17 0.00 0.00 -6.47(~2.21) -5.51(~6.01) -1.42(~3.84) 10.00(~****) -4.20(~6.70) # # # DOPPLER REACT.COEF.benchmark # ---------------------------- DOPPLER comparison COEFF.OF REACTIVITY (pcm/K) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : DOPPLER.O E(wt%) DOPPLER COEF.(pcm/K)-DIF(%) ================================================= REF 0.711 -5.98( 0.00) -5.21( 14.75) REF 1.600 -3.71( 0.00) -3.36( 10.36) REF 2.400 -3.03( 0.00) -2.67( 13.48) REF 3.100 -2.71( 0.00) -2.73( -0.71) REF 3.900 -2.58( 0.00) -2.36( 9.35) ================================================= Average ( 0.00) Dif/St.Dv 9.45( 10.90) # # # RTC React.Coeffic. benchmark # ---------------------------- RTC-DIFFS.BETWEEN CALCULATION AND MEASUREMENTS ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : RTC.O Case D-ALPHA(pcm/C) ================================================= NORA-1.66 (-1.507140) NORA-3.03 (-1.644597) KRITZ1 (-0.843287) KRITZ21 (-0.778671) KRITZ213 (-1.593725) KRITZ219 (-2.168055) VVER1 (-8.473417) VVER2 (-5.320021) VVER3 (-4.844977) VVER4 (-2.470295) ================================================= Average ( 0.000000) Dif/St.Dv-2.964418( 3.784331) # # # Uranium D2O Gd exper. benchmarks # ---------------------------------- Thermal Neutron Flux Distribution Ai:Annulus i;Mj:Moderator (j:cm) ================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis Case COO A1 DIF.% A2 DIF.% A3NG DIF.% A3WG DIF.% M11 DIF.% M16 DIF.% M22 DIF.% ============================================================================================== Gd:NO H2O 0.30( 33.3) 0.32( 31.3) 0.55( 18.2) 1.10( 9.1) 1.40( 7.1) 1.50( 6.7) 0.23( -32.1) 0.23( -37.0) 0.43( -29.3) 1.08( -2.2) 1.41( 0.9) 1.54( 2.6) Gd:NO AIR 0.38( 26.3) 0.55( 18.2) 0.75( 13.3) 1.20( 8.3) 2.05( 4.9) 2.30( 4.3) 0.40( 5.0) 0.48( -15.5) 0.67( -11.2) 1.21( 0.9) 2.13( 3.7) 2.47( 7.0) Gd:YES H2O 0.15( 100.0) 0.17( 88.2) 0.06(250.0) 1.18( 12.7) 1.68( 8.9) 1.87( 8.0) 0.22( 32.0) 0.11( -49.7) 0.07( 10.5) 1.13( -4.8) 1.70( 1.0) 1.89( 0.9) ============================================================================================== Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.H2O coolant-cluster without poison =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.30( 33.33) 0.23( -32.12) 5.76 0.32( 31.25) 0.23( -37.02) 7.68 0.55( 18.18) 0.43( -29.32) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.02( 9.80) 1.01( -0.87) 10.25 1.05( 9.52) 1.02( -3.17) 11.00 1.10( 9.09) 1.08( -2.23) 12.00 1.20( 8.33) 1.17( -2.62) 13.00 1.25( 8.00) 1.25( -0.35) 14.00 1.26( 7.94) 1.31( 3.91) 15.00 1.37( 7.30) 1.37( -0.26) 16.00 1.40( 7.14) 1.41( 0.91) 17.00 1.45( 6.90) 1.45( 0.07) 18.00 1.40( 7.14) 1.48( 5.52) 19.00 1.45( 6.90) 1.51( 3.70) 20.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.52( 1.52) 21.00 1.47( 6.80) 1.53( 4.20) 22.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.54( 2.55) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.AIR coolant-cluster without poison =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.38( 26.32) 0.40( 4.96) 5.76 0.55( 18.18) 0.48( -15.48) 7.68 0.75( 13.33) 0.67( -11.17) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.05( 9.52) 1.04( -1.38) 10.25 1.10( 9.09) 1.06( -4.05) 11.00 1.20( 8.33) 1.21( 0.90) 12.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.46( -2.43) 13.00 1.70( 5.88) 1.68( -1.48) 14.00 1.80( 5.56) 1.85( 2.88) 15.00 1.90( 5.26) 2.00( 5.18) 16.00 2.05( 4.88) 2.13( 3.73) 17.00 2.12( 4.72) 2.23( 5.06) 18.00 2.20( 4.55) 2.32( 5.03) 19.00 2.25( 4.44) 2.38( 5.52) 20.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.43( 5.29) 21.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.46( 6.48) 22.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.47( 6.97) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.12 poisoned fuel pins on 3rd.layer =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.15( 66.67) 0.22( 31.98) 5.76 0.17( 58.82) 0.11( -49.74) 7.68 0.06( 166.67) 0.07( 10.53) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.02( 9.80) 1.02( 0.19) 10.25 1.07( 9.35) 1.03( -3.54) 11.00 1.18( 8.47) 1.13( -4.79) 12.00 1.35( 7.41) 1.28( -5.46) 13.00 1.43( 6.99) 1.41( -1.39) 14.00 1.54( 6.49) 1.52( -1.16) 15.00 1.62( 6.17) 1.62( -0.18) 16.00 1.68( 5.95) 1.70( 0.99) 17.00 1.75( 5.71) 1.76( 0.72) 18.00 1.80( 5.56) 1.82( 0.86) 19.00 1.85( 5.41) 1.86( 0.37) 20.00 1.87( 5.35) 1.89( 0.90) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.-Average Dy-reaction rate on pins =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis Case Dy-RR DIF.% ======================= Gd:NO 0.922( 3.471) 0.916( -0.687) Gd:0.1wt% 0.723( 4.011) 0.662( -9.148) Gd:0.5wt% 0.424( 3.774) 0.395( -7.350) Gd:1.0wt% 0.317( 3.470) 0.312( -1.608) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # # # MTR - OWR burnup benchmark # -------------------------- MTR-OWR comparison AVERAGE VALUES (W%U235)(DIFF.) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : MTRBURN.lis CYC W%U235 ============================================ E-CYCLE 1 91.7( 2.0) 91.5(-0.2) E-CYCLE 2 89.9( 2.0) 89.4(-0.5) E-CYCLE 3 88.4( 2.0) 87.6(-0.8) E-CYCLE 4 87.1( 2.0) 86.1(-1.0) E-CYCLE 5 85.9( 2.0) 84.6(-1.3) E-CYCLE 6 82.8( 2.0) 81.0(-1.8) E-CYCLE 7 80.6( 2.0) 78.5(-2.1) E-CYCLE 8 79.1( 2.0) 76.7(-2.4) E-CYCLE 9 77.1( 2.0) 74.4(-2.7) E-CYCLE10 75.3( 2.0) 72.2(-3.1) E-CYCLE11 72.9( 2.0) 69.4(-3.5) E-CYCLE12 69.5( 2.0) 65.5(-4.0) E-CYCLE13 67.1( 2.0) 62.8(-4.3) E-CYCLE14 65.7( 2.0) 61.0(-4.7) E-CYCLE15 63.7( 2.0) 58.7(-5.0) E-CYCLE16 60.4( 2.0) 54.9(-5.5) E-CYCLE17 58.4( 2.0) 52.6(-5.8) ============================================ Average Dif/St.Dv # MTR-OWR comparison Atomic Densities for Actinides ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : MTRBURN.lis NAME AT.DENS.(EOCycle17) CALC.-REF. ============================================ U234 1.12E-05( 0.00E+00) 1.07E-05(-5.43E-07) U235 9.28E-04( 0.00E+00) 9.14E-04(-1.43E-05) U236 1.02E-04( 0.00E+00) 1.10E-04( 8.46E-06) U238 1.04E-04( 0.00E+00) 1.02E-04(-2.13E-06) Np237 1.07E-06( 0.00E+00) 1.95E-06( 8.81E-07) Pu238 6.03E-08( 0.00E+00) 1.58E-07( 9.73E-08) Pu239 4.51E-07( 0.00E+00) 1.72E-06( 1.27E-06) Pu240 7.46E-08( 0.00E+00) 3.04E-07( 2.29E-07) Pu241 1.23E-08( 0.00E+00) 9.51E-08( 8.28E-08) Pu242 1.51E-09( 0.00E+00) 1.06E-08( 9.04E-09) Am241 1.54E-09( 0.00E+00) 3.70E-09( 2.16E-09) Am242 0.00E+00( 0.00E+00) 2.40E-12( 2.40E-12) Am242m 3.51E-12( 0.00E+00) 3.19E-11( 2.84E-11) Am243 3.12E-11( 0.00E+00) 3.05E-10( 2.74E-10) Cm242 2.36E-12( 0.00E+00) 3.09E-10( 3.07E-10) Cm243 1.31E-13( 0.00E+00) 1.47E-12( 1.34E-12) Cm244 1.13E-12( 0.00E+00) 1.42E-11( 1.31E-11) ============================================ Average Dif/St.Dv # # # PWR - Th burnup benchmark # ------------------------- PWR THORIUM PIN CELL BURNUP BENCHMARK ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : thburn.lst B(MWd/kgHM) Kinfinity diff(%) ================================================= 0.000 1.23782E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.25199E+00 ( 1.14) 0.114 1.20071E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.21422E+00 ( 1.13) 5.835 1.14828E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.15918E+00 ( 0.95) 10.411 1.12108E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.13157E+00 ( 0.94) 19.563 1.07245E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.08324E+00 ( 1.01) 31.004 1.02014E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.03043E+00 ( 1.01) 40.156 9.81900E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.91923E-01 ( 1.02) 49.308 9.46360E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.56387E-01 ( 1.06) 51.596 9.38170E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.48011E-01 ( 1.05) 60.749 9.07010E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.16884E-01 ( 1.09) 72.189 8.73480E-01 ( 0.0 ) 8.83760E-01 ( 1.18) ================================================= Average Dif/St.Dv # PWR THORIUM PIN CELL BURNUP BENCHMARK ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : thburn.lst ISOTOPE AtomDens. diff(%) ================================================= Th-232 1.53769E-02 ( 0.0 ) 1.53708E-02 ( -0.04) Pa-231 1.70440E-06 ( 0.0 ) 1.42763E-06 ( -16.24) Pa-233 1.95229E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.99126E-05 ( 2.00) U -232 1.56006E-06 ( 0.0 ) 1.33811E-06 ( -14.23) U -233 2.74202E-04 ( 0.0 ) 2.76500E-04 ( 0.84) U -234 5.15172E-05 ( 0.0 ) 5.17610E-05 ( 0.47) U -235 1.78104E-04 ( 0.0 ) 1.73262E-04 ( -2.72) U -236 1.39420E-04 ( 0.0 ) 1.40437E-04 ( 0.73) U -238 3.88419E-03 ( 0.0 ) 3.90303E-03 ( 0.49) Np-237 1.82660E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.70086E-05 ( -6.88) Np-239 7.61806E-07 ( 0.0 ) 7.31643E-07 ( -3.96) Pu-238 8.90932E-06 ( 0.0 ) 8.56009E-06 ( -3.92) Pu-239 5.37090E-05 ( 0.0 ) 4.99922E-05 ( -6.92) Pu-240 1.82233E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.78621E-05 ( -1.98) Pu-241 1.90707E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.80217E-05 ( -5.50) Pu-242 9.96772E-06 ( 0.0 ) 9.62651E-06 ( -3.42) ================================================= Average Dif/St.Dv #