# # WLUP STANDARD BENCHMARK SEQUENCE # -------------------------------- # # Uranium criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------ SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrume.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== aecl_um 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99808(-.19) 0.720 0.0652 0.1367 1.109 aere_uma1 1.00000(~.80) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00343(0.34) 2.409 0.2011 0.1997 1.526 aere_uma2 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00033(0.03) 2.096 0.1839 0.1983 1.406 aere_uma3 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99115(-.90) 1.325 0.1164 0.1560 1.109 aere_uma4 1.00000(~.27) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99292(-.72) 0.994 0.0875 0.1338 0.972 aere_uma5 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00530(0.53) 1.011 0.0891 0.1348 0.979 hw_uma1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99172(-.84) 1.538 0.1366 0.1706 1.165 hw_uma2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99102(-.91) 1.279 0.1139 0.1553 1.064 hw_uma3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99486(-.52) 1.104 0.0984 0.1439 0.994 hw_uma4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99179(-.83) 0.872 0.0780 0.1288 0.898 hw_umb1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99072(-.94) 1.541 0.1300 0.1522 1.103 hw_umb2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99272(-.74) 1.113 0.0939 0.1261 0.942 hw_umb3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00022(0.02) 1.014 0.0856 0.1193 0.904 hw_umb4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99208(-.80) 2.143 0.1924 0.2035 1.309 hw_umb5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99245(-.76) 1.405 0.1273 0.1662 1.050 hw_umb6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98940(-1.1) 1.059 0.0964 0.1462 0.920 bnl_uma1 1.00000(~.16) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98940(-1.1) 1.445 0.0975 0.1098 1.071 bnl_uma2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99275(-.73) 1.023 0.0665 0.0835 0.905 bnl_uma3 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99537(-.47) 0.807 0.0515 0.0692 0.817 bnl_uma4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99046(-.97) 1.710 0.1263 0.1362 1.164 bnl_uma5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99056(-.96) 0.922 0.0655 0.0873 0.862 bnl_uma6 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98826(-1.2) 2.316 0.1857 0.1787 1.369 bnl_uma7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98907(-1.1) 0.659 0.0512 0.0806 0.754 bnl_umb1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98821(-1.2) 1.877 0.1307 0.1326 1.217 bnl_umb2 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99283(-.72) 1.456 0.0982 0.1093 1.063 bnl_umb3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99403(-.60) 1.030 0.0670 0.0833 0.898 bnl_umb4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99414(-.59) 0.813 0.0518 0.0690 0.810 bnl_umb5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99366(-.64) 1.723 0.1272 0.1357 1.156 bnl_umb6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99235(-.77) 1.325 0.0960 0.1126 1.010 bnl_umb7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99431(-.57) 0.928 0.0659 0.0869 0.855 bnl_umb8 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99243(-.76) 0.730 0.0514 0.0733 0.775 bnl_umb9 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99121(-.89) 2.334 0.1870 0.1780 1.360 bnl_umb10 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99022(-.99) 1.202 0.0940 0.1168 0.960 bnl_umb11 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99196(-.81) 0.840 0.0653 0.0926 0.819 bnl_umb12 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99301(-.71) 0.663 0.0515 0.0802 0.748 bnl_umb13 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98878(-1.1) 1.677 0.1370 0.1514 1.132 bnl_umb14 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99176(-.83) 0.997 0.0810 0.1099 0.880 bnl_umb15 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98936(-1.1) 0.844 0.0685 0.0996 0.820 bnl_umb16 1.00000(~.16) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98848(-1.2) 0.661 0.0538 0.0871 0.747 aere_umb1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99444(-.56) 1.541 0.1335 0.1493 0.971 aere_umb2 1.00000(~.25) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99756(-.24) 1.151 0.1000 0.1275 0.843 bnl_umc1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99134(-.88) 0.875 0.0556 0.0672 0.750 bnl_umc2 1.00000(~.21) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99177(-.83) 1.704 0.1336 0.1362 1.028 bnl_umd1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99268(-.74) 2.063 0.1508 0.1297 1.009 bnl_umd2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99238(-.77) 1.579 0.1133 0.1073 0.873 bnl_umd3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99152(-.86) 1.099 0.0773 0.0825 0.729 bnl_umd4 1.00000(~.23) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99441(-.56) 1.093 0.0768 0.0820 0.727 bnl_umd5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99294(-.71) 0.860 0.0599 0.0691 0.654 bnl_umd6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99154(-.86) 0.995 0.0764 0.0877 0.695 bnl_umd7 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99260(-.75) 0.781 0.0600 0.0756 0.628 trx_um1 1.00000(~.30) 1.320(~1.6) 0.0987(~1.0) 0.0946(~4.3) 0.797(~1.0) 0.99269(-.74) 1.370(3.80) 0.0974(-1.3) 0.0963(1.84) 0.806(1.10) trx_um2 1.00000(~.10) 0.837(~1.9) 0.0614(~1.3) 0.0693(~5.1) 0.647(~.93) 0.99461(-.54) 0.859(2.68) 0.0599(-2.5) 0.0687(-.87) 0.649(0.37) hw_umc1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99453(-.55) 2.100 0.1804 0.1572 0.906 hw_umc2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99876(-.12) 1.750 0.1508 0.1428 0.822 hw_umc3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00067(0.07) 1.496 0.1292 0.1316 0.758 hw_umc4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00465(0.46) 1.171 0.1015 0.1165 0.673 hw_umc5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00486(0.48) 0.973 0.0845 0.1074 0.619 srl_um1 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01836(1.79) 4.400 0.3531 0.1601 0.663 srl_um2 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00962(0.95) 3.080 0.2494 0.1368 0.537 srl_um3 1.00000(~.28) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99798(-.20) 2.466 0.2005 0.1250 0.473 srl_um4 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99214(-.80) 8.448 0.6590 0.2264 0.960 srl_um5 1.00000(~.31) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00970(0.96) 5.337 0.4243 0.1887 0.740 srl_um6 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99957(-.04) 4.012 0.3216 0.1695 0.626 srl_um7 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99254(-.75) 3.261 0.2623 0.1573 0.555 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.24 1.76 1.17 4.71 0.97 -0.55(~0.57) 3.24(~0.56) -1.91(~0.58) 0.49(~1.35) 0.74(~0.37) # # # Uranium UO2 criticality benchmarks # ---------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcruo2.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== bapl1 1.00000(~.10) 1.390(~.72) 0.0840(~2.4) 0.0780(~5.1) 0.000 0.99923(-.08) 1.420(2.15) 0.0823(-2.1) 0.0749(-4.0) 0.816 bapl2 1.00000(~.10) 1.120(~.89) 0.0680(~1.5) 0.0700(~5.7) 0.000 0.99912(-.09) 1.182(5.50) 0.0671(-1.3) 0.0645(-7.9) 0.744 bapl3 1.00000(~.10) 0.906(~1.1) 0.0520(~1.9) 0.0570(~5.3) 0.000 0.99969(-.03) 0.928(2.46) 0.0516(-.67) 0.0529(-7.1) 0.665 bapl4 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0710(~9.9) 0.000 0.99171(-.84) 1.331 0.0780 0.0736(3.72) 0.799 bapl5 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0590(~ 10) 0.000 0.99447(-.56) 1.061 0.0610 0.0613(3.98) 0.715 bapl6 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0510(~7.8) 0.000 0.99386(-.62) 0.886 0.0503 0.0531(4.14) 0.659 naig_nca 1.00000(~.40) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00592(0.59) 1.063 0.0580 0.0419 0.463 curl_zpr1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00317(0.32) 2.505 0.1561 0.0887 0.717 curl_zpr2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98762(-1.3) 1.351 0.0813 0.0565 0.507 curl_zpr3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0460(~2.2) 0.000 0.99743(-.26) 0.962 0.0574 0.0441(-4.2) 0.431 curl_zpr4 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99667(-.33) 0.767 0.0457 0.0379 0.391 baw_bay2a 1.00000(~.25) 2.280(~1.3) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01219(1.20) 2.335(2.39) 0.1337 0.0673 0.580 baw_cx10 1.00000(~.13) 1.850(~1.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99386(-.62) 1.809(-2.2) 0.1010 0.0552 0.500 aerl_ocf1 1.00000(~.22) 1.350(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0430(~4.7) 0.000 1.00326(0.32) 1.424(5.50) 0.0778 0.0448(4.28) 0.433 aerl_ocf2 1.00000(~.40) 1.050(~3.8) 0.0000 0.0330(~6.1) 0.000 1.00463(0.46) 1.078(2.67) 0.0580 0.0359(8.82) 0.377 jaeritca1 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99370(-.64) 1.969 0.1112 0.0576 0.498 jaeritca2 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99237(-.77) 1.760 0.0985 0.0527 0.467 jaeritca3 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98916(-1.1) 1.515 0.0839 0.0467 0.430 jaeritca4 1.00000(~.33) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01030(1.01) 2.217 0.1296 0.0642 0.525 jaeritca5 1.00000(~.19) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99683(-.32) 1.860 0.1074 0.0563 0.474 jaeritca6 1.00000(~.23) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99966(-.03) 1.428 0.0812 0.0458 0.410 jaeritca7 1.00000(~.40) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00512(0.51) 1.215 0.0687 0.0405 0.377 wapd_crxa1 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00373(0.37) 3.765 0.2105 0.0829 0.714 wapd_crxa2 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00135(0.13) 3.329 0.1831 0.0755 0.661 wapd_crxa3 1.00000(~.13) 0.000 0.1580(~3.8) 0.0760(~2.6) 0.000 1.00415(0.41) 2.889 0.1560(-1.3) 0.0674( -11) 0.605 wapd_crxa4 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0600(~8.3) 0.000 1.00148(0.15) 2.264 0.1187 0.0553(-7.8) 0.521 wapd_crxa5 1.00000(~.15) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.470(~2.1) 0.99568(-.43) 1.980 0.1023 0.0496 0.481(2.43) wapd_crxa6 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01177(1.16) 0.991 0.0487 0.0280 0.334 aeewjuno 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99611(-.39) 1.679 0.0907 0.0438 0.392 r1100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0928(~.97) 0.629(~.72) 1.00134(0.13) 4.015 0.2336 0.0857(-7.7) 0.656(4.30) r2100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00237(0.24) 1.429 0.0766 0.0381 0.354 r3100h 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.1113(~1.6) 0.725(~1.1) 1.00042(0.04) 5.113 0.3050 0.1017(-8.6) 0.762(5.02) dimp1a 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0962(~3.3) 0.647(~.46) 1.00066(0.06) 4.010 0.2328 0.0854( -11) 0.654(1.11) bnluo2_1 1.00000(~.05) 2.920(~3.1) 0.0000 0.0650(~1.5) 0.000 0.99484(-.52) 2.983(2.16) 0.1669 0.0660(1.49) 0.552 bnluo2_2 1.00000(~.16) 2.410(~1.7) 0.0000 0.0560(~1.8) 0.000 0.98825(-1.2) 2.457(1.96) 0.1354 0.0571(1.98) 0.489 bnluo2_3 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0480(~2.1) 0.000 0.99045(-.97) 1.967 0.1067 0.0481(0.23) 0.429 bnluo2_4 1.00000(~.16) 1.410(~1.4) 0.0000 0.0370(~1.1) 0.000 0.99293(-.71) 1.495(6.01) 0.0800 0.0390(5.38) 0.367 bnluo2_5 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0310(~ 19) 0.000 0.98967(-1.0) 1.115 0.0591 0.0315(1.52) 0.316 anl_zpr7a1 1.00000(~.05) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99689(-.31) 8.747 0.5462 0.1419 1.046 anl_zpr7a2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99455(-.55) 4.997 0.2955 0.1004 0.751 anl_zpr7a3 1.00000(~.26) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99176(-.83) 3.956 0.2289 0.0851 0.649 anl_zpr7a4 1.00000(~.10) 4.120(~.73) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99778(-.22) 4.359(5.81) 0.2506 0.0864 0.692 anl_zpr7a5 1.00000(~.26) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98844(-1.2) 2.859 0.1593 0.0660 0.530 npy_nora1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0620(~4.8) 0.000 1.00537(0.53) 2.680 0.1539 0.0595(-4.0) 0.452 npy_nora2 1.00000(~.32) 1.524(~1.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00818(0.81) 1.562(2.50) 0.0876 0.0397 0.330 npy_nora3 1.00000(~.26) 1.065(~1.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00388(0.39) 1.122(5.40) 0.0626 0.0316 0.278 wapd_crxb1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0780(~6.4) 0.000 1.00436(0.43) 4.338 0.2354 0.0713(-8.6) 0.569 wapd_crxb2 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.408(~4.9) 1.00079(0.08) 2.541 0.1300 0.0465 0.406(-.59) sckvenus1 1.00000(~.48) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99299(-.71) 3.610 0.1945 0.0603 0.465 sckvenus2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99697(-.30) 1.454 0.0736 0.0291 0.269 baw_bay2b1 1.00000(~.33) 5.080(~6.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98780(-1.2) 5.012(-1.3) 0.2852 0.0795 0.569 baw_bay2b2 1.00000(~.12) 4.120(~7.5) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99263(-.74) 4.229(2.66) 0.2371 0.0701 0.511 wapd_crxc 1.00000(~.24) 0.000 0.2510(~8.0) 0.0700(~7.1) 0.000 0.99714(-.29) 4.699 0.2485(-1.0) 0.0636(-9.1) 0.499 anl_zpr7b1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00167(0.17) 5.767 0.3125 0.0710 0.506 anl_zpr7b2 1.00000(~.53) 0.000 0.2430(~ 21) 0.0650(~9.2) 0.000 1.00355(0.35) 4.409 0.2334(-4.0) 0.0581( -11) 0.426 wapd_crxd1 1.00000(~.49) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00202(0.20) 5.018 0.2643 0.0569 0.397 wapd_crxd2 1.00000(~.36) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01291(1.27) 3.938 0.2033 0.0470 0.340 wapd_crxd3 1.00000(~.21) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00949(0.94) 1.668 0.0823 0.0241 0.200 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.28 3.05 9.24 6.88 2.47 -0.12(~0.64) 2.91(~2.38) -1.71(~1.09) -2.90(~6.14) 2.45(~2.05) # # # WWER criticality benchmarks # --------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : wwercr.ref Compared file : jendl3.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== p2w1b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98781(-1.2) 1.482 0.0800 0.0615 0.694 p2w1b4t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98565(-1.5) 1.574 0.0851 0.0641 0.717 p3w1b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99860(-.14) 0.953 0.0489 0.0421 0.558 p2w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00078(0.08) 2.936 0.1542 0.0541 0.456 p2w2b0t2 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99617(-.38) 3.027 0.1591 0.0554 0.468 p2w2b0t3 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99450(-.55) 3.153 0.1660 0.0572 0.483 p2w2b5t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00569(0.56) 3.168 0.1669 0.0566 0.479 p2w2b5t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00098(0.10) 3.260 0.1717 0.0579 0.491 p2w2b5t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00075(0.07) 3.386 0.1786 0.0595 0.506 p2w2b6t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00276(0.27) 3.276 0.1727 0.0579 0.489 p2w2b6t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00418(0.42) 3.365 0.1773 0.0590 0.501 p2w2b6t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00085(0.08) 3.493 0.1843 0.0607 0.516 p2w2b7t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00589(0.58) 3.357 0.1771 0.0587 0.497 p1w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98694(-1.3) 5.211 0.2938 0.0843 0.654 p1w2b0t2 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.97899(-2.2) 5.398 0.3039 0.0864 0.673 p1w2b0t3 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.97567(-2.5) 5.647 0.3183 0.0890 0.696 p1w2b2t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99163(-.85) 5.266 0.2971 0.0846 0.659 p1w2b3t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98917(-1.1) 5.294 0.2986 0.0850 0.661 p3w2b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00215(0.21) 1.821 0.0911 0.0364 0.341 p3w2b5t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01050(1.03) 2.055 0.1032 0.0394 0.367 p4w2b0t1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00783(0.77) 1.066 0.0516 0.0236 0.257 p2w3b0t1 1.00000(~.60) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99534(-.47) 3.541 0.1842 0.0530 0.418 p2w3b1t1 1.00000(~.70) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00220(0.22) 3.576 0.1861 0.0532 0.421 p2w3b7t1 1.00000(~.80) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01295(1.27) 3.979 0.2078 0.0565 0.451 p3w3b0t1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99633(-.37) 2.175 0.1078 0.0355 0.308 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.56 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -0.28(~0.93) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # LWR MOX criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------ SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrmox.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== ge_pu1 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00565(0.56) 4.009 0.2299 1.1054 9.235 ge_pu2 1.00000(~.30) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00885(0.87) 2.745 0.1517 0.8337 7.300 ge_pu3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01420(1.39) 1.568 0.0830 0.5340 5.266 ge_pu4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01406(1.38) 1.144 0.0596 0.4160 4.474 ge_pu5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01485(1.45) 0.876 0.0453 0.3403 3.958 ge_pu6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01581(1.54) 0.819 0.0423 0.3242 3.846 wcrx_pu1 1.00000(~.34) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00459(0.45) 5.306 0.3125 0.4718 3.346 wcrx_pu2 1.00000(~.27) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00264(0.26) 3.669 0.2103 0.3665 2.658 wcrx_pu3 1.00000(~.31) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01327(1.30) 1.445 0.0781 0.1788 1.534 wcrx_pu4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01235(1.21) 1.180 0.0636 0.1551 1.383 wcrx_pu5 1.00000(~.08) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00824(0.81) 0.774 0.0426 0.1261 1.144 wcrx_pu6 1.00000(~.35) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00544(0.54) 13.480 0.7171 0.9733 6.027 jtca_pu1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99723(-.28) 2.225 0.1014 0.2130 1.985 jtca_pu2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99951(-.05) 1.817 0.0817 0.1802 1.760 jtca_pu3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00333(0.33) 1.310 0.0581 0.1387 1.469 jtca_pu4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00552(0.55) 1.039 0.0459 0.1168 1.309 bnw_pua1 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00033(0.03) 3.870 0.2221 0.3807 2.749 bnw_pua2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01787(1.74) 2.258 0.1261 0.2559 1.972 bnw_pua3 1.00000(~.11) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02088(2.02) 1.600 0.0885 0.1988 1.619 bnw_pua4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01920(1.87) 1.301 0.0717 0.1719 1.451 bnw_pua5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01233(1.21) 0.961 0.0529 0.1418 1.255 bnw_pua6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02181(2.11) 0.923 0.0509 0.1382 1.233 bnw_pua7 1.00000(~.50) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00301(0.30) 0.693 0.0383 0.1209 1.095 bnw_pua8 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99473(-.53) 0.688 0.0380 0.1208 1.092 bnw_pub1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01717(1.67) 2.150 0.1183 0.2428 1.918 bnw_pub2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01926(1.87) 1.524 0.0830 0.1886 1.578 bnw_pub3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02163(2.09) 1.237 0.0672 0.1629 1.416 bnw_pub4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01524(1.49) 0.915 0.0497 0.1345 1.228 bnw_pub5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02133(2.07) 0.880 0.0478 0.1313 1.207 bnw_puc1 1.00000(~.12) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00478(0.47) 3.526 0.1976 0.3451 2.600 bnw_puc2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01260(1.24) 2.058 0.1124 0.2320 1.870 bnw_puc3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02023(1.96) 1.458 0.0788 0.1798 1.542 bnw_puc4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01585(1.55) 1.186 0.0640 0.1558 1.387 bnw_puc5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00490(0.49) 0.879 0.0474 0.1291 1.207 bnw_puc6 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02065(2.00) 0.844 0.0455 0.1256 1.186 bnw_pud1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00644(0.64) 6.441 0.3528 0.5871 3.841 bnw_pud2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01548(1.51) 5.019 0.2711 0.4967 3.282 bnw_pud3 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01690(1.65) 3.638 0.1936 0.3976 2.672 bnw_pud4 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01591(1.55) 1.324 0.0694 0.2033 1.471 bnw_pud5 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00394(0.39) 0.938 0.0495 0.1744 1.246 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.19 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.09(~0.72) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Intermediate spectrum criticality benchmarks # -------------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : expcrisp.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== hiss1 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01442(1.41) 99.999 10.0000 0.0004 0.054 hiss2 1.00000(~.10) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01452(1.42) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.42(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # BNL-Th2-U3-H2O criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ==================================== Reference file : expbnlh.ref Compared file : jendl3.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== BNL_THH2O1 1.00000(~.76) 1.380(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01607(1.57) 1.139( -17) 0.5815 0.0174 0.595 BNL_THH2O2 1.00000(~.45) 0.928(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01250(1.23) 0.798( -14) 0.4194 0.0143 0.561 BNL_THH2O3 1.00000(~.65) 0.754(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01359(1.33) 0.640( -15) 0.3413 0.0125 0.543 BNL_THH2O4 1.00000(~.49) 0.607(~4.3) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01324(1.30) 0.501( -17) 0.2708 0.0108 0.526 BNL_THH2O5 1.00000(~.24) 0.435(~3.0) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01211(1.19) 0.372( -14) 0.2042 0.0089 0.510 BNL_THH2O6 1.00000(~.29) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01193(1.17) 0.273 0.1517 0.0073 0.495 BNL_THH2O7 1.00000(~.06) 0.218(~3.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00828(0.82) 0.188( -14) 0.1058 0.0059 0.483 BNL_THH2O8 1.00000(~.10) 0.170(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00376(0.37) 0.152( -11) 0.0863 0.0054 0.477 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.45 3.66 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.12(~0.34)-14.70(~2.19) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) 0.00(~0.00) # # # BNL-Th2-U3-D2O criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ==================================== Reference file : expbnld.ref Compared file : jendl3.SMR LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== BNL-TD2O-1 1.00000(~.22) 5.190(~ 10) 0.0000 0.0117(~6.8) 0.000 1.01776(1.73) 4.187( -19) 1.7920 0.0112(-4.2) 0.790 BNL-TD2O-2 1.00000(~.28) 0.780(~4.1) 0.0000 0.0056(~ 13) 0.000 0.99554(-.45) 0.753(-3.5) 0.3968 0.0049( -13) 0.555 BNL-TD2O-3 1.00000(~.40) 0.559(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0047(~ 15) 0.000 0.99640(-.36) 0.535(-4.3) 0.2893 0.0042( -11) 0.529 BNL-TD2O-4 1.00000(~.27) 0.297(~3.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99104(-.91) 0.292(-1.5) 0.1639 0.0034 0.497 BNL-TD2O-5 1.00000(~.75) 0.234(~3.4) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99829(-.17) 0.225(-3.7) 0.1278 0.0032 0.487 BNL-TD2O-6 1.00000(~.59) 0.166(~3.6) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99121(-.89) 0.158(-4.6) 0.0906 0.0030 0.477 BNL-TD2O-7 1.00000(~.99) 0.104(~4.8) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01181(1.16) 0.109(5.29) 0.0629 0.0028 0.470 BNL-TD2O-8 1.00000(~.68) 0.089(~5.6) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01345(1.32) 0.078( -13) 0.0442 0.0027 0.465 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.58 5.35 0.00 11.90 0.00 0.18(~0.99) -5.54(~6.94) 0.00(~0.00) -9.62(~3.94) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Uranium D2O criticality benchmarks # ---------------------------------- D2OSMR - Summarize WLUP D2O Benchmarks ====================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 2 cases : e1t1.lis 2 cases : e1t2.lis 1 case : e1t3.lis 4 cases : e1t4.lis 6 cases : e2t1.lis LATTICE K-eff Del ConvR CuA LuR =========================================================================== ZED2T1D2O 1.00000(0.00) 0.0511( 1.5) 1.4138( 0.3) 1.140(1.00) 1.206(0.40) 1.00254(0.25) 0.0516( 0.9) 1.4260( 0.9) 1.146(0.83) 1.223(1.39) ZED2T1Air 1.00000(0.00) 0.0583( 1.5) 1.3765( 0.3) 1.146(1.00) 1.223(0.40) 1.00621(0.62) 0.0591( 1.4) 1.3772( 0.1) 1.146(0.60) 1.243(1.61) ZED2T2p24 1.00000(0.00) 0.0580( 1.5) 0.9258( 0.6) 0.99558(-.44) 0.0523(-9.9) 0.9091(-1.8) ZED2T2p40 1.00000(0.00) 0.0547( 1.5) 0.7663( 0.6) 1.00303(0.30) 0.0482(****) 0.7372(-3.8) ZED2T3p24 1.00000(0.00) 1.00121(0.12) ZED2T4D22 1.00000(0.00) 0.0071(10.0) 1.00110(0.11) 0.0084(18.8) ZED2T4A22 1.00000(0.00) 0.0069(10.0) 1.00487(0.49) 0.0095(37.0) ZED2T4D28 1.00000(0.00) 0.0061(10.0) 0.99957(-.04) 0.0082(33.5) ZED2T4A28 1.00000(0.00) 0.0069(10.0) 1.00119(0.12) 0.0092(33.4) DCAT1D22 1.00000(0.00) 1.00077(0.08) DCAT1A22 1.00000(0.00) 0.99996(0.00) DCAT1H22 1.00000(0.00) 1.00124(0.12) DCAT1D25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00083(0.08) DCAT1A25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00088(0.09) DCAT1H25 1.00000(0.00) 1.00170(0.17) =========================================================================== Average (0.00) ( 5.8) ( 0.5) (1.00) (0.40) Dif/St.Dv 0.14(0.27) 12.9(22.9) -1.2( 2.1) 0.71(0.72) 1.50(1.50) # # # IRPhE D2O criticality benchmarks # -------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : critd2o.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== minor1 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98315(-1.7) 1.027 0.0925 0.0745 1.270 minor1 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98871(-1.1) 0.640 0.0575 0.0651 1.053 minor1 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99114(-.90) 0.449 0.0401 0.0609 0.941 minor1 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99511(-.49) 0.339 0.0300 0.0587 0.876 minor1 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99475(-.53) 0.271 0.0237 0.0577 0.835 minor1 6 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99444(-.56) 0.226 0.0195 0.0572 0.808 minor1 7 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99558(-.44) 0.158 0.0128 0.0567 0.766 minor2 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98789(-1.2) 0.597 0.0506 0.0520 1.028 minor2 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98976(-1.0) 0.473 0.0401 0.0492 0.955 minor2 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99096(-.92) 0.387 0.0327 0.0474 0.904 minor2 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99354(-.65) 0.324 0.0273 0.0461 0.866 minor2 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99365(-.64) 0.277 0.0233 0.0452 0.837 minor2 6 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99395(-.61) 0.213 0.0177 0.0443 0.798 minor2 7 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99266(-.74) 0.172 0.0142 0.0438 0.773 minor3 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.98841(-1.2) 0.598 0.0507 0.0521 1.029 minor3 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99448(-.56) 0.277 0.0233 0.0453 0.837 minor4 1 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99190(-.82) 0.421 0.0386 0.0742 0.925 minor4 2 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99425(-.58) 0.347 0.0313 0.0729 0.882 minor4 3 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99406(-.60) 0.297 0.0263 0.0723 0.852 minor4 4 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99139(-.87) 0.263 0.0228 0.0722 0.832 minor4 5 1.00000(~.20) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99544(-.46) 0.238 0.0202 0.0718 0.817 srlur 7 1.00000(~.45) 0.181 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 0.99808(-.19) 0.233( 29) 0.0201 0.0540(5.84) 0.812 srlur 8 1.00000(~.50) 0.132 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 0.99971(-.03) 0.189( 43) 0.0159 0.0535(4.84) 0.785 srlur 9 1.00000(~.65) 0.114 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00285(0.28) 0.157( 38) 0.0129 0.0531(4.18) 0.765 srlur 12 1.00000(~.85) 0.086 0.0000 0.0510(~3.9) 0.000 1.00522(0.52) 0.126( 47) 0.0097 0.0530(3.98) 0.746 norahw s1 1.00000(~.44) 0.374(~6.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99783(-.22) 0.371(-.88) 0.0195 0.0114 0.208 norahw s2 1.00000(~.56) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02662(2.56) 0.784 0.0409 0.0124 0.267 norahw s3 1.00000(~.45) 1.540(~2.9) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02294(2.22) 1.360( -12) 0.0711 0.0146 0.347 norahw s4 1.00000(~.23) 2.570(~2.7) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99896(-.10) 2.493(-3.0) 0.1327 0.0197 0.492 norahw s6 1.00000(~.72) 3.480(~3.2) 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.00875(0.86) 3.151(-9.4) 0.1699 0.0224 0.570 wlrx 65x65 1.00000(~.20) 0.740(~5.4) 0.0535(~.37) 0.0453(~.44) 0.000 0.98934(-1.1) 0.865( 17) 0.0541(1.07) 0.0315( -31) 0.771 wlrx 65x80 1.00000(~.30) 0.671(~1.5) 0.0000 0.0483(~2.9) 0.000 1.00205(0.20) 0.684(1.98) 0.0427 0.0298( -38) 0.702 wlrx 80x80 1.00000(~.45) 0.493(~.61) 0.0450(~2.2) 0.0356(~.56) 0.000 1.00863(0.85) 0.553( 12) 0.0344( -23) 0.0287( -19) 0.651 dimpsghw1 1.00000(~.46) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 0.99690(-.31) 1.686 0.1203 0.0554 1.025 dimpsghw2 1.00000(~.37) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01075(1.06) 1.525 0.0941 0.0389 0.980 dimpsghw5 1.00000(~.15) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.03062(2.93) 0.775 0.0425 0.0362 0.709 dimpsghw3 1.00000(~.17) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.01046(1.03) 1.253 0.0739 0.0381 0.884 dimpsghw4 1.00000(~.14) 0.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.000 1.02238(2.16) 1.055 0.0603 0.0370 0.813 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.34 3.05 1.59 3.17 0.00 -0.10(~1.09) 14.73(~****) -11.21(~****) -9.92(~****) 0.00(~0.00) # # # Uranium D2O burnup benchmark # ---------------------------- D2OE3B comparison AVERAGE VALUES (Ni/Nj%)(delta%) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E3.lis BUP N25/N28 N26/N28 N49/N28 N40/N49 N41/N49 N42/N4 ============================================================================ EXP 3250 0.438( 2.0) 0.044( 2.0) 0.178( 2.0) 16.50( 2.0) 2.240( 2.0) 0.220( 2.0) 0.435(-0.8) 0.043(-1.0) 0.176(-1.3) 17.15( 4.0) 2.353( 5.0) 0.221( 0.4) EXP 6500 0.247( 2.0) 0.074( 2.0) 0.242( 2.0) 34.30( 2.0) 6.290( 2.0) 1.580( 2.0) 0.258( 4.4) 0.070(-6.0) 0.240(-1.0) 34.01(-0.9) 6.420( 2.1) 1.419(-10.2) EXP 10800 0.122( 2.0) 0.089( 2.0) 0.267( 2.0) 53.60( 2.0)11.140( 2.0) 5.110( 2.0) 0.123( 0.6) 0.089(-0.3) 0.265(-0.7) 55.57( 3.7)12.000( 7.7) 5.254( 2.8) ============================================================================ Average ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) ( 2.0) Dif/St.Dv 1.27( 1.5) -3.78( 2.4) -2.15( 2.2) 2.38( 1.8) 5.22( 1.7) -2.13( 4.7) # # # NEA/CRP Burnup Credit Criticality Benchmarks # Part-1A: Criticality prediction # -------------------------------------------- WEDB1A - NEA Burnup Credit Benchmark ==================================== Part-1A Criticality Prediction Calculated results filename: : bucr1a.OUT Delta K = K(Case n) - K(Case 1) Second row gives: Uncertainty (2 sigma) for reference Difference from reference for cal. Third row gives the same in % CASE K - REF. K - CAL. DELTA K-REF. DELTA K-CAL. 1 1.43780 1.44228 0 0 1750 448 0 0 0.31 0.00 2 1.14020 1.13869 -29760 -30359 1689 -150 1339 -599 -0.13 2.01 3 1.06380 1.06159 -37400 -38069 1700 -221 1539 -669 -0.21 1.79 4 1.24560 1.24788 -19220 -19440 1070 227 970 -220 0.18 1.15 5 1.18850 1.18989 -24930 -25239 1099 139 1070 -309 0.12 1.24 6 1.11230 1.11140 -32550 -33088 1640 -90 1489 -538 -0.08 1.65 7 1.02400 1.02227 -41380 -42001 1559 -173 1470 -621 -0.17 1.50 8 1.22840 1.23154 -20939 -21074 1090 313 989 -134 0.26 0.64 9 1.16570 1.16737 -27210 -27491 989 167 1140 -281 0.14 1.03 10 1.26350 1.26522 -17430 -17706 1080 171 999 -276 0.14 1.59 11 1.25660 1.25848 -18119 -18380 1090 187 970 -260 0.15 1.44 # # # NEA/CRP Burnup Credit Criticality Benchmarks # Part-1B: Isotopic composition prediction # -------------------------------------------- WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.96498 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.602E-01 0.1 1.600E-01 0.0 U -235 8.217E+00 -3.0 8.470E+00 0.0 U -236 3.130E+00 -0.3 3.140E+00 0.0 U -238 8.375E+02 -0.6 8.425E+02 0.0 Pu-238 8.423E-02 -16.8 1.012E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.132E+00 -3.1 4.264E+00 0.0 Pu-240 1.693E+00 -1.5 1.719E+00 0.0 Pu-241 6.610E-01 -3.0 6.812E-01 0.0 Pu-242 2.765E-01 -4.2 2.886E-01 0.0 Am-241 2.414E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 3.462E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 2.747E-01 2.5 2.680E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 5.678E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 5.897E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 5.596E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 3.529E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 6.071E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 8.522E-01 0.3 8.500E-01 0.0 Cs-135 3.758E-01 4.4 3.600E-01 0.0 Nd-143 6.111E-01 -0.3 6.130E-01 0.0 Nd-145 5.109E-01 0.2 5.100E-01 0.0 Sm-147 1.855E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 1.841E-03 -36.5 2.900E-03 0.0 Sm-150 1.883E-01 -9.1 2.070E-01 0.0 Sm-151 8.620E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 9.802E-02 12.7 8.700E-02 0.0 Eu-153 7.785E-02 -1.5 7.900E-02 0.0 Gd-155 2.677E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 3.560E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | I | U -235 | ----+ | U -236 | + | U -238 | -+ | Pu-238 | -------------------------+ | Pu-239 | -----+ | Pu-240 | --+ | Pu-241 | ----+ | Pu-242 | ------+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | +---- | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | I | Cs-135 | +------- | Nd-143 | I | Nd-145 | I | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | --------------+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +------------------- | Eu-153 | --+ | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.96498 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.603E-01 0.8 1.590E-01 5.2 U -235 8.317E+00 1.6 8.190E+00 3.0 U -236 3.117E+00 -3.3 3.224E+00 2.9 U -238 8.375E+02 0.0 8.375E+02 0.1 Pu-238 8.491E-02 -10.7 9.504E-02 8.5 Pu-239 4.246E+00 0.4 4.230E+00 5.2 Pu-240 1.704E+00 -0.3 1.710E+00 4.0 Pu-241 6.773E-01 1.1 6.697E-01 6.4 Pu-242 2.784E-01 0.8 2.761E-01 8.7 Am-241 2.414E-01 -0.5 2.426E-01 4.2 Am-243 3.462E-02 -15.6 4.101E-02 11.3 Np-237 2.772E-01 -4.8 2.912E-01 8.6 Mo- 95 5.678E-01 0.2 5.666E-01 1.2 Tc- 99 5.897E-01 -1.5 5.985E-01 5.2 Ru-101 5.596E-01 -0.7 5.637E-01 1.0 Rh-103 3.529E-01 1.1 3.492E-01 4.6 Ag-109 6.071E-02 3.0 5.892E-02 7.1 Cs-133 8.522E-01 1.3 8.415E-01 4.9 Cs-135 3.758E-01 -1.6 3.821E-01 2.9 Nd-143 6.130E-01 -1.6 6.232E-01 2.8 Nd-145 5.104E-01 0.8 5.066E-01 1.0 Sm-147 1.855E-01 2.7 1.806E-01 6.0 Sm-149 1.875E-03 -8.7 2.054E-03 14.1 Sm-150 1.886E-01 -3.4 1.953E-01 5.3 Sm-151 8.620E-03 -11.5 9.742E-03 22.4 Sm-152 9.792E-02 4.2 9.394E-02 7.2 Eu-153 7.824E-02 2.2 7.655E-02 7.9 Gd-155 2.677E-03 -31.0 3.879E-03 33.5 Gd-157 3.560E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 27.35 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b1.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +- X | U -235 | +-- X | U -236 | -X---+ | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | ---X------------+ | Pu-239 | +- X | Pu-240 | X I | Pu-241 | +-- X | Pu-242 | +- X | Am-241 | X -+ | Am-243 | ------X----------------+ | Np-237 | X -------+ | Mo- 95 | I X | Tc- 99 | X --+ | Ru-101 | X-+ | Rh-103 | +-- X | Ag-109 | +----- X | Cs-133 | +-- X | Cs-135 | X --+ | Nd-143 | X --+ | Nd-145 | +-X | Sm-147 | +---- X | Sm-149 | X -------------+ | Sm-150 | X -----+ | Sm-151 | -----------------+ | Sm-152 | +------ X | Eu-153 | +--- X | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.87684 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.375E-01 -1.8 1.400E-01 0.0 U -235 4.829E+00 -6.6 5.170E+00 0.0 U -236 3.542E+00 0.3 3.530E+00 0.0 U -238 8.303E+02 -0.3 8.327E+02 0.0 Pu-238 1.624E-01 -14.2 1.893E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.203E+00 -3.5 4.357E+00 0.0 Pu-240 2.190E+00 -2.2 2.239E+00 0.0 Pu-241 8.734E-01 -3.3 9.028E-01 0.0 Pu-242 5.699E-01 -1.1 5.761E-01 0.0 Am-241 3.111E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 9.959E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 3.953E-01 11.0 3.560E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 7.356E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 7.693E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 7.562E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 4.485E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 9.298E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 1.101E+00 1.0 1.090E+00 0.0 Cs-135 4.081E-01 2.0 4.000E-01 0.0 Nd-143 7.094E-01 -0.9 7.160E-01 0.0 Nd-145 6.529E-01 0.0 6.530E-01 0.0 Sm-147 2.072E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 1.976E-03 -34.1 3.000E-03 0.0 Sm-150 2.616E-01 -3.5 2.710E-01 0.0 Sm-151 9.548E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 1.256E-01 20.8 1.040E-01 0.0 Eu-153 1.179E-01 8.2 1.090E-01 0.0 Gd-155 4.340E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 3.867E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | ---+ | U -235 | ----------+ | U -236 | +- | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | ---------------------+ | Pu-239 | -----+ | Pu-240 | ---+ | Pu-241 | -----+ | Pu-242 | --+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | +----------------- | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | +-- | Cs-135 | +--- | Nd-143 | -+ | Nd-145 | I | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | -----+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +-----------------------------> Eu-153 | +------------ | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.87684 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.379E-01 1.2 1.363E-01 7.1 U -235 4.928E+00 1.0 4.879E+00 6.0 U -236 3.528E+00 -2.9 3.633E+00 2.8 U -238 8.303E+02 0.0 8.304E+02 0.2 Pu-238 1.636E-01 -10.9 1.835E-01 7.5 Pu-239 4.306E+00 -0.2 4.314E+00 6.1 Pu-240 2.201E+00 0.6 2.189E+00 4.3 Pu-241 8.930E-01 0.8 8.859E-01 6.0 Pu-242 5.710E-01 2.1 5.593E-01 8.3 Am-241 3.111E-01 -0.2 3.119E-01 4.3 Am-243 9.959E-02 -12.4 1.137E-01 10.4 Np-237 3.985E-01 -4.7 4.183E-01 8.9 Mo- 95 7.356E-01 0.3 7.333E-01 1.3 Tc- 99 7.693E-01 -0.7 7.745E-01 3.6 Ru-101 7.562E-01 -0.6 7.611E-01 1.0 Rh-103 4.485E-01 1.1 4.436E-01 5.2 Ag-109 9.298E-02 8.5 8.570E-02 7.0 Cs-133 1.102E+00 1.6 1.085E+00 4.9 Cs-135 4.081E-01 -1.6 4.148E-01 3.2 Nd-143 7.129E-01 -2.2 7.292E-01 3.9 Nd-145 6.529E-01 1.2 6.454E-01 1.3 Sm-147 2.072E-01 3.1 2.010E-01 7.9 Sm-149 2.008E-03 -9.0 2.208E-03 15.0 Sm-150 2.616E-01 -4.5 2.738E-01 7.1 Sm-151 9.548E-03 -12.6 1.092E-02 21.7 Sm-152 1.254E-01 4.9 1.195E-01 9.0 Eu-153 1.184E-01 4.0 1.139E-01 8.2 Gd-155 4.340E-03 -35.0 6.676E-03 33.3 Gd-157 3.867E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 37.12 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b2.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +-- X | U -235 | +- X | U -236 | X---+ | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | -----X----------+ | Pu-239 | X I | Pu-240 | +- X | Pu-241 | +- X | Pu-242 | +--- X | Am-241 | X I | Am-243 | ---X---------------+ | Np-237 | X -------+ | Mo- 95 | I X | Tc- 99 | X -+ | Ru-101 | X-+ | Rh-103 | +-- X | Ag-109 | +---------X--- | Cs-133 | +-- X | Cs-135 | X --+ | Nd-143 | X ---+ | Nd-145 | +-X | Sm-147 | +----- X | Sm-149 | X --------------+ | Sm-150 | X -------+ | Sm-151 | -------------------+ | Sm-152 | +------- X | Eu-153 | +------ X | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.82282 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.227E-01 2.3 1.200E-01 0.0 U -235 3.236E+00 -8.6 3.540E+00 0.0 U -236 3.678E+00 -0.3 3.690E+00 0.0 U -238 8.245E+02 -0.1 8.249E+02 0.0 Pu-238 2.335E-01 -13.1 2.688E-01 0.0 Pu-239 4.294E+00 -1.4 4.357E+00 0.0 Pu-240 2.472E+00 -2.8 2.543E+00 0.0 Pu-241 9.982E-01 -2.1 1.020E+00 0.0 Pu-242 8.203E-01 -2.4 8.401E-01 0.0 Am-241 3.393E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Am-243 1.739E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Np-237 4.814E-01 2.9 4.680E-01 0.0 Mo- 95 8.487E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Tc- 99 8.905E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ru-101 8.986E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Rh-103 5.047E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Ag-109 1.172E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Cs-133 1.264E+00 1.9 1.240E+00 0.0 Cs-135 4.246E-01 -1.2 4.300E-01 0.0 Nd-143 7.550E-01 -1.0 7.630E-01 0.0 Nd-145 7.443E-01 0.0 7.440E-01 0.0 Sm-147 2.135E-01 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-149 2.138E-03 -54.5 4.700E-03 0.0 Sm-150 3.143E-01 -12.9 3.610E-01 0.0 Sm-151 1.018E-02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Sm-152 1.425E-01 17.8 1.210E-01 0.0 Eu-153 1.472E-01 -0.5 1.480E-01 0.0 Gd-155 5.603E-03 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 Gd-157 4.018E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Measured values) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BM.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +--- | U -235 | -------------+ | U -236 | I | U -238 | I | Pu-238 | --------------------+ | Pu-239 | --+ | Pu-240 | ----+ | Pu-241 | ---+ | Pu-242 | ----+ | Am-241 | 0 | Am-243 | 0 | Np-237 | +---- | Mo- 95 | 0 | Tc- 99 | 0 | Ru-101 | 0 | Rh-103 | 0 | Ag-109 | 0 | Cs-133 | +--- | Cs-135 | --+ | Nd-143 | --+ | Nd-145 | I | Sm-147 | 0 | Sm-149 <-----------------------------+ | Sm-150 | -------------------+ | Sm-151 | 0 | Sm-152 | +--------------------------- | Eu-153 | -+ | Gd-155 | 0 | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | 0 | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.82282 ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 1.233E-01 1.5 1.215E-01 9.0 U -235 3.204E+00 0.1 3.201E+00 8.1 U -236 3.671E+00 -2.6 3.769E+00 2.6 U -238 8.245E+02 -0.4 8.274E+02 0.2 Pu-238 2.301E-01 -10.5 2.572E-01 6.6 Pu-239 4.268E+00 -0.8 4.303E+00 7.1 Pu-240 2.464E+00 1.1 2.437E+00 5.3 Pu-241 9.942E-01 0.5 9.892E-01 6.9 Pu-242 8.261E-01 3.5 7.985E-01 8.4 Am-241 3.393E-01 -0.3 3.403E-01 5.3 Am-243 1.739E-01 -9.3 1.917E-01 10.4 Np-237 4.785E-01 -4.4 5.005E-01 9.4 Mo- 95 8.487E-01 0.6 8.440E-01 1.9 Tc- 99 8.905E-01 -0.6 8.958E-01 4.2 Ru-101 8.986E-01 -0.4 9.021E-01 1.8 Rh-103 5.047E-01 1.2 4.989E-01 5.4 Ag-109 1.172E-01 11.3 1.053E-01 7.6 Cs-133 1.267E+00 1.8 1.244E+00 5.6 Cs-135 4.246E-01 -1.7 4.318E-01 4.4 Nd-143 7.528E-01 -2.8 7.748E-01 4.5 Nd-145 7.451E-01 1.5 7.339E-01 1.5 Sm-147 2.135E-01 3.2 2.070E-01 9.1 Sm-149 2.114E-03 -9.5 2.336E-03 15.6 Sm-150 3.134E-01 -5.4 3.311E-01 8.5 Sm-151 1.018E-02 -13.1 1.171E-02 22.3 Sm-152 1.429E-01 5.5 1.355E-01 9.7 Eu-153 1.474E-01 5.5 1.397E-01 8.5 Gd-155 5.603E-03 -36.7 8.849E-03 33.0 Gd-157 4.018E-05 0.0 0.000E+00 0.0 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.0 1.185E+02 0.0 # ************************************* OECD/NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark Phase 1B (Average results) ************************************* Burnup = 44.34 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : bucr1b3.OUT Reference results : BUCR1BA.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +-- X | U -235 | I X | U -236 | X---+ | U -238 | -+ | Pu-238 | ------X---------+ | Pu-239 | X -+ | Pu-240 | +-- X | Pu-241 | +- X | Pu-242 | +----- X | Am-241 | X I | Am-243 | X --------------+ | Np-237 | X -------+ | Mo- 95 | +- X | Tc- 99 | X -+ | Ru-101 | X -+ | Rh-103 | +-- X | Ag-109 | +----------X------ | Cs-133 | +--- X | Cs-135 | X --+ | Nd-143 | X ----+ | Nd-145 | +-X | Sm-147 | +----- X | Sm-149 | X --------------+ | Sm-150 | X --------+ | Sm-151 | --------------------+ | Sm-152 | +-------- X | Eu-153 | +-------- X | Gd-155 <-----------------------------+ | Gd-157 | 0 | O - 16 | I | # # # NEA/CRP Plutonium Recycling Benchmarks # -------------------------------------- WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark A - Highly degraded Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.94161 ************************ Calculated results : purecya.OUT Reference results : purecya.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 8.224E-02 1.6 8.095E-02 3.0 U -235 3.054E+00 2.1 2.991E+00 1.0 U -236 5.470E-01 -4.8 5.746E-01 3.2 U -238 7.398E+02 0.0 7.397E+02 0.1 Np-237 2.068E-01 6.0 1.952E-01 9.5 Pu-238 3.525E+00 1.1 3.485E+00 4.7 Pu-239 2.512E+01 1.5 2.475E+01 1.2 Pu-240 2.347E+01 -3.5 2.431E+01 3.2 Pu-241 1.357E+01 3.9 1.306E+01 3.4 Pu-242 2.095E+01 4.2 2.010E+01 8.2 Am-241 1.344E+00 5.9 1.269E+00 3.9 Am-242m 3.519E-02 9.9 3.202E-02 16.9 Am-243 3.066E+00 -16.6 3.677E+00 25.6 Cm-242 1.884E-01 -7.8 2.043E-01 5.3 Cm-243 7.167E-03 -12.0 8.149E-03 7.3 Cm-244 1.617E+00 -1.2 1.637E+00 3.8 Mo- 95 7.944E-01 5.1 7.557E-01 8.0 Tc- 99 1.018E+00 2.3 9.956E-01 5.9 Ru-101 1.059E+00 -1.7 1.077E+00 2.1 Rh-103 9.463E-01 -1.6 9.619E-01 4.5 Pd-105 9.624E-01 -1.9 9.811E-01 2.5 Pd-107 6.863E-01 0.6 6.822E-01 1.4 Pd-108 4.958E-01 0.9 4.914E-01 3.3 Ag-109 2.801E-01 22.0 2.295E-01 18.7 Xe-131 5.975E-01 -0.3 5.994E-01 6.9 Xe-135 5.277E-04 4.2 5.065E-04 2.8 Cs-133 1.473E+00 3.3 1.426E+00 5.3 Cs-135 1.286E+00 2.0 1.260E+00 1.7 Nd-143 1.103E+00 -5.3 1.165E+00 13.7 Nd-145 7.927E-01 -1.2 8.026E-01 5.7 Pm-147 2.098E-01 8.6 1.932E-01 29.3 Pm-148m 4.393E-03 11.8 3.928E-03 12.6 Sm-149 1.229E-02 -8.5 1.343E-02 18.6 Sm-150 3.664E-01 -5.3 3.869E-01 7.3 Sm-151 6.216E-02 -7.0 6.683E-02 31.4 Sm-152 1.916E-01 5.5 1.817E-01 15.8 Eu-153 2.088E-01 8.4 1.927E-01 11.5 Eu-154 6.743E-02 -6.0 7.170E-02 16.8 Eu-155 1.640E-02 -24.6 2.176E-02 40.2 O - 16 1.184E+02 0.0 1.184E+02 0.0 # ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark A - Highly degraded Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : purecya.OUT Reference results : purecya.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +-- X | U -235 | +-X- | U -236 | --X----+ | U -238 | I | Np-237 | +--------- X | Pu-238 | +-- X | Pu-239 | +-X | Pu-240 | X----+ | Pu-241 | +----X- | Pu-242 | +------ X | Am-241 | +-----X--- | Am-242m| +--------------- X | Am-243 | -------------------------+ | Cm-242 | ----X-------+ | Cm-243 | -------X----------+ | Cm-244 | X --+ | Mo- 95 | +-------- X | Tc- 99 | +--- X | Ru-101 | X--+ | Rh-103 | X --+ | Pd-105 | X---+ | Pd-107 | +-X | Pd-108 | +- X | Ag-109 | +---------------------------X-> Xe-131 | X I | Xe-135 | +---X-- | Cs-133 | +----- X | Cs-135 | +--X | Nd-143 | X --------+ | Nd-145 | X --+ | Pm-147 | +------------- | Pm-148m| +------------------X | Sm-149 | X -------------+ | Sm-150 | X --------+ | Sm-151 | ----------+ | Sm-152 | +-------- X | Eu-153 | +------------- X | Eu-154 | X ---------+ | Eu-155 <-----------------------------+ | O - 16 | I | # WEDB1B - Isotopic composition comparison ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark B - Normal PWR recycled Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU k-inf = 0.91637 ************************ Calculated results : purecyb.OUT Reference results : purecyb.REF Isotope Calculated Diff. Reference Sigma [mg/gFuel] [%] [mg/gFuel] [%] ------------------------------------------- U -234 2.134E-02 12.1 1.904E-02 26.3 U -235 8.230E-01 3.1 7.984E-01 1.1 U -236 2.405E-01 -3.7 2.499E-01 2.5 U -238 8.004E+02 0.0 8.000E+02 0.1 Np-237 1.611E-01 9.2 1.476E-01 11.1 Pu-238 8.139E-01 1.1 8.054E-01 10.8 Pu-239 1.237E+01 2.4 1.208E+01 2.5 Pu-240 9.682E+00 -2.8 9.957E+00 2.8 Pu-241 6.428E+00 3.0 6.240E+00 1.3 Pu-242 4.155E+00 6.0 3.921E+00 6.8 Am-241 4.704E-01 8.1 4.351E-01 3.8 Am-242m 1.024E-02 12.8 9.080E-03 20.8 Am-243 9.860E-01 -12.4 1.125E+00 9.0 Cm-242 1.162E-01 -12.0 1.320E-01 6.5 Cm-243 4.364E-03 -20.9 5.519E-03 18.7 Cm-244 5.836E-01 -17.5 7.072E-01 5.6 Mo- 95 7.828E-01 6.0 7.384E-01 6.7 Tc- 99 9.856E-01 0.8 9.775E-01 4.6 Ru-101 1.045E+00 -2.0 1.067E+00 1.6 Rh-103 8.171E-01 -3.6 8.478E-01 3.1 Pd-105 9.369E-01 -3.2 9.674E-01 1.8 Pd-107 6.695E-01 -0.1 6.705E-01 2.1 Pd-108 4.757E-01 -2.6 4.886E-01 2.0 Ag-109 2.564E-01 20.4 2.130E-01 18.1 Xe-131 5.632E-01 -1.0 5.689E-01 6.7 Xe-135 3.223E-04 3.3 3.119E-04 3.2 Cs-133 1.421E+00 2.1 1.392E+00 4.3 Cs-135 9.029E-01 2.8 8.780E-01 2.9 Nd-143 9.845E-01 -5.9 1.046E+00 12.7 Nd-145 7.592E-01 -2.1 7.757E-01 5.7 Pm-147 1.862E-01 0.7 1.848E-01 22.2 Pm-148m 2.883E-03 2.4 2.815E-03 6.5 Sm-149 4.902E-03 -6.0 5.213E-03 12.0 Sm-150 3.792E-01 -6.5 4.057E-01 5.0 Sm-151 3.133E-02 -0.3 3.142E-02 26.5 Sm-152 1.853E-01 3.2 1.796E-01 15.9 Eu-153 2.140E-01 4.9 2.041E-01 9.5 Eu-154 5.926E-02 -22.4 7.634E-02 18.3 Eu-155 1.663E-02 -11.4 1.877E-02 27.9 O - 16 1.185E+02 0.1 1.184E+02 0.0 # ************************************************************* Physics of Plutonium Recycling Benchmark B - Normal PWR recycled Plutonium Nuclide Densities of Actinides and Fission Products, 1/(b cm) ************************************************************* Burnup = 50.00 GWd/tU ************************ Calculated results : purecyb.OUT Reference results : purecyb.REF Legend: --- Error bar X Uncertainty 0 Zero or no data Isot. V_-20% _______________________V________________________+20%_V U -234 | +------------------ | U -235 | +-X--- | U -236 | --X---+ | U -238 | I | Np-237 | +-------------- X | Pu-238 | +-- X | Pu-239 | +---X | Pu-240 | X---+ | Pu-241 | +-X--- | Pu-242 | +---------X | Am-241 | +-----X------ | Am-242m| +------------------- | Am-243 | ------X------------+ | Cm-242 | --------X---------+ | Cm-243 <-X---------------------------+ | Cm-244 | ------------------X-------+ | Mo- 95 | +---------X | Tc- 99 | +- X | Ru-101 | -X-+ | Rh-103 | X----+ | Pd-105 | --X--+ | Pd-107 | X I | Pd-108 | -X--+ | Ag-109 | +--------------------------X--> Xe-131 | X --+ | Xe-135 | +----X | Cs-133 | +--- X | Cs-135 | +---X | Nd-143 | X ---------+ | Nd-145 | X ---+ | Pm-147 | +- | Pm-148m| +---- X | Sm-149 | X ---------+ | Sm-150 | ---X------+ | Sm-151 | I | Sm-152 | +----- X | Eu-153 | +------- X | Eu-154 <--X--------------------------+ | Eu-155 | -----------------+ | O - 16 | I | # # # Rowlands PinCell Benchmarks # --------------------------- Rowlands Pin-cell Uranium Benchmark =================================== Case summary ------------ Case Tfuel Tcan Tmod. RhoW B**2 (K) (K) (K) (g/cm3) (1/cm2) 1,5 290 293 293 1.0 0.01 2,6 293 293 293 0.7 0.01 3,7 900 600 550 0.7 0.01 4,8 550 550 550 0.7 0.01 NOTE: - Reference results contain the uncertainty in braces [pcm] - WIMS results contain the difference from reference in braces [pcm] Multiplication factors K-inf ---------------------------- Case 1 2 3 4 Ref. 1.38796( 82) 1.33613( 107) 1.30385( 127) 1.31843( 168) WIMS 1.38575(-221) 1.33274(-339) 1.29955(-430) 1.31491(-352) Multiplication factors K-eff ---------------------------- Case 5 6 7 8 Ref. 0.99676( 356) 0.81517( 370) 0.79301( 378) 0.80113( 201) WIMS 0.99856( 180) 0.81751( 234) 0.79400( 99) 0.80287( 174) Change in K-inf due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 1-2 2-4 4-3 2-3 1-3 Ref. 5183( 49) 1771( 97) 1458( 92) 3229( 39) 8411( 50) WIMS 5301( 118) 1783( 12) 1536( 78) 3319( 90) 8620( 209) Change in K-inf due to leakage [pcm] ------------------------------------ Case 1-5 2-6 3-7 4-8 Ref. 39120( 85) 52097( 213) 51084( 219) 51729( 232) WIMS 38720(-400) 51524(-573) 50555(-529) 51204(-525) Change in K-eff due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 5-6 6-8 8-7 6-7 Ref. 18160( 174) 1403( 9) 813( 20) 2216( 24) WIMS 18105( -55) 1437( 34) 863( 50) 2300( 84) Rowlands Plutonium Pin-cell Benchmark ===================================== Case summary ------------ Case Material Tfuel Tcan Tmod (K) (K) (K) 1 MOX-1 300 300 300 2 MOX-1 560 300 300 3 MOX-2 560 300 300 4 MOX-2 300 300 300 NOTE: - Reference results contain the uncertainty in braces [pcm] - WIMS results contain the difference from reference in braces [pcm] Multiplication factors K-inf ---------------------------- Case 1 2 3 4 Ref. 1.21951( 133) 1.20507( 143) 1.24911( 79) 1.26246( 152) WIMS 1.20682(****) 1.19209(****) 1.24871( -40) 1.26319( 73) Change in K-inf due to temperature[pcm] --------------------------------------- Case 1-2 4-3 Ref. 1444( 40) 1335( 64) WIMS 1473( 29) 1448( 113) # # # WLUP SUPPLEMENTARY BENCHMARK SEQUENCE # ------------------------------------- # # U-H2O-Be criticality benchmarks # ------------------------------- SMRDIF - Compare lattice spectr.indices ======================================= Reference file : bermar.ref Compared file : jendl3.smr LATTICE K-eff Rho28 Del25 Del28 ConvR ====================================================================== ber-tubes 1.68681(~.03) 8.545(~.11) 0.0528(~.19) 0.0001 0.011 1.62188(-2.4) 7.538( -12) 0.0535(1.29) 0.0001( 30) 0.010( -11) ber-hom 1.00036(~.06) 13.150(~.01) 0.0699(~.14) 0.0001 0.016 0.95971(-4.3) 13.196(0.35) 0.0657(-6.0) 0.0001( -10) 0.016(1.87) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Average 0.05 0.07 0.17 0.00 0.00 -3.37(~0.95) -5.71(~6.06) -2.37(~3.66) 10.00(~****) -4.52(~6.39) # # # DOPPLER REACT.COEF.benchmark # ---------------------------- DOPPLER comparison COEFF.OF REACTIVITY (pcm/K) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : DOPPLER.O E(wt%) DOPPLER COEF.(pcm/K)-DIF(%) ================================================= REF 0.711 -6.01( 0.00) -5.21( 15.31) REF 1.600 -3.73( 0.00) -3.36( 11.16) REF 2.400 -3.06( 0.00) -2.67( 14.71) REF 3.100 -2.75( 0.00) -2.73( 0.60) REF 3.900 -2.62( 0.00) -2.36( 11.07) ================================================= Average ( 0.00) Dif/St.Dv 10.57( 11.82) # # # RTC React.Coeffic. benchmark # ---------------------------- RTC-DIFFS.BETWEEN CALCULATION AND MEASUREMENTS ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : RTC.O Case D-ALPHA(pcm/C) ================================================= NORA-1.66 (-1.357952) NORA-3.03 (-1.638512) KRITZ1 (-1.134647) KRITZ21 (-1.186109) KRITZ213 (-2.050467) KRITZ219 (-2.264122) VVER1 (-8.799663) VVER2 (-5.533841) VVER3 (-4.962656) VVER4 (-2.588516) ================================================= Average ( 0.000000) Dif/St.Dv-3.151649( 3.948918) # # # Uranium D2O Gd exper. benchmarks # ---------------------------------- Thermal Neutron Flux Distribution Ai:Annulus i;Mj:Moderator (j:cm) ================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis Case COO A1 DIF.% A2 DIF.% A3NG DIF.% A3WG DIF.% M11 DIF.% M16 DIF.% M22 DIF.% ============================================================================================== Gd:NO H2O 0.30( 33.3) 0.32( 31.3) 0.55( 18.2) 1.10( 9.1) 1.40( 7.1) 1.50( 6.7) 0.23( -29.9) 0.24( -35.2) 0.43( -28.1) 1.08( -2.2) 1.41( 0.9) 1.54( 2.6) Gd:NO AIR 0.38( 26.3) 0.55( 18.2) 0.75( 13.3) 1.20( 8.3) 2.05( 4.9) 2.30( 4.3) 0.40( 5.3) 0.48( -15.2) 0.68( -11.0) 1.21( 0.9) 2.12( 3.4) 2.46( 6.6) Gd:YES H2O 0.15( 100.0) 0.17( 88.2) 0.06(250.0) 1.18( 12.7) 1.68( 8.9) 1.87( 8.0) 0.22( 33.1) 0.12( -47.3) 0.07( 12.0) 1.13( -4.7) 1.70( 1.0) 1.89( 0.8) ============================================================================================== Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.H2O coolant-cluster without poison =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.30( 33.33) 0.23( -29.93) 5.76 0.32( 31.25) 0.24( -35.16) 7.68 0.55( 18.18) 0.43( -28.13) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.02( 9.80) 1.01( -0.89) 10.25 1.05( 9.52) 1.02( -3.17) 11.00 1.10( 9.09) 1.08( -2.18) 12.00 1.20( 8.33) 1.17( -2.53) 13.00 1.25( 8.00) 1.25( -0.28) 14.00 1.26( 7.94) 1.31( 3.97) 15.00 1.37( 7.30) 1.37( -0.22) 16.00 1.40( 7.14) 1.41( 0.94) 17.00 1.45( 6.90) 1.45( 0.10) 18.00 1.40( 7.14) 1.48( 5.54) 19.00 1.45( 6.90) 1.51( 3.71) 20.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.52( 1.53) 21.00 1.47( 6.80) 1.53( 4.21) 22.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.54( 2.55) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.AIR coolant-cluster without poison =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.38( 26.32) 0.40( 5.28) 5.76 0.55( 18.18) 0.48( -15.19) 7.68 0.75( 13.33) 0.68( -10.98) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.05( 9.52) 1.04( -1.35) 10.25 1.10( 9.09) 1.06( -4.00) 11.00 1.20( 8.33) 1.21( 0.94) 12.00 1.50( 6.67) 1.46( -2.49) 13.00 1.70( 5.88) 1.67( -1.63) 14.00 1.80( 5.56) 1.85( 2.67) 15.00 1.90( 5.26) 2.00( 4.92) 16.00 2.05( 4.88) 2.12( 3.43) 17.00 2.12( 4.72) 2.23( 4.74) 18.00 2.20( 4.55) 2.31( 4.68) 19.00 2.25( 4.44) 2.37( 5.16) 20.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.42( 4.92) 21.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.45( 6.11) 22.00 2.30( 4.35) 2.46( 6.59) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.12 poisoned fuel pins on 3rd.layer =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis R(cm) FLUX DIF.% ======================= 3.83 0.15( 66.67) 0.22( 33.12) 5.76 0.17( 58.82) 0.12( -47.25) 7.68 0.06( 166.67) 0.07( 12.03) 9.25 1.00( 10.00) 1.00( 0.00) 9.75 1.02( 9.80) 1.02( 0.19) 10.25 1.07( 9.35) 1.03( -3.51) 11.00 1.18( 8.47) 1.13( -4.71) 12.00 1.35( 7.41) 1.28( -5.38) 13.00 1.43( 6.99) 1.41( -1.35) 14.00 1.54( 6.49) 1.52( -1.15) 15.00 1.62( 6.17) 1.62( -0.20) 16.00 1.68( 5.95) 1.70( 0.95) 17.00 1.75( 5.71) 1.76( 0.66) 18.00 1.80( 5.56) 1.81( 0.79) 19.00 1.85( 5.41) 1.86( 0.29) 20.00 1.87( 5.35) 1.89( 0.81) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # Therm.Flux Distr.-Average Dy-reaction rate on pins =================================================== Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : E2T2.lis Case Dy-RR DIF.% ======================= Gd:NO 0.922( 3.471) 0.915( -0.720) Gd:0.1wt% 0.723( 4.011) 0.662( -9.248) Gd:0.5wt% 0.424( 3.774) 0.394( -7.605) Gd:1.0wt% 0.317( 3.470) 0.311( -2.037) ======================= Average Dif/St.Dv # # # MTR - OWR burnup benchmark # -------------------------- MTR-OWR comparison AVERAGE VALUES (W%U235)(DIFF.) ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : MTRBURN.lis CYC W%U235 ============================================ E-CYCLE 1 91.7( 2.0) 91.5(-0.2) E-CYCLE 2 89.9( 2.0) 89.4(-0.5) E-CYCLE 3 88.4( 2.0) 87.6(-0.8) E-CYCLE 4 87.1( 2.0) 86.0(-1.1) E-CYCLE 5 85.9( 2.0) 84.6(-1.3) E-CYCLE 6 82.8( 2.0) 81.0(-1.8) E-CYCLE 7 80.6( 2.0) 78.5(-2.1) E-CYCLE 8 79.1( 2.0) 76.7(-2.4) E-CYCLE 9 77.1( 2.0) 74.4(-2.7) E-CYCLE10 75.3( 2.0) 72.2(-3.1) E-CYCLE11 72.9( 2.0) 69.4(-3.5) E-CYCLE12 69.5( 2.0) 65.5(-4.0) E-CYCLE13 67.1( 2.0) 62.7(-4.4) E-CYCLE14 65.7( 2.0) 61.0(-4.7) E-CYCLE15 63.7( 2.0) 58.7(-5.0) E-CYCLE16 60.4( 2.0) 54.8(-5.6) E-CYCLE17 58.4( 2.0) 52.5(-5.9) ============================================ Average Dif/St.Dv # MTR-OWR comparison Atomic Densities for Actinides ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : MTRBURN.lis NAME AT.DENS.(EOCycle17) CALC.-REF. ============================================ U234 1.12E-05( 0.00E+00) 1.07E-05(-4.74E-07) U235 9.28E-04( 0.00E+00) 9.13E-04(-1.52E-05) U236 1.02E-04( 0.00E+00) 1.10E-04( 8.41E-06) U238 1.04E-04( 0.00E+00) 1.02E-04(-2.13E-06) Np237 1.07E-06( 0.00E+00) 1.97E-06( 8.96E-07) Pu238 6.03E-08( 0.00E+00) 1.48E-07( 8.78E-08) Pu239 4.51E-07( 0.00E+00) 1.72E-06( 1.27E-06) Pu240 7.46E-08( 0.00E+00) 3.08E-07( 2.33E-07) Pu241 1.23E-08( 0.00E+00) 9.26E-08( 8.03E-08) Pu242 1.51E-09( 0.00E+00) 1.03E-08( 8.78E-09) Am241 1.54E-09( 0.00E+00) 3.64E-09( 2.10E-09) Am242 0.00E+00( 0.00E+00) 1.50E-12( 1.50E-12) Am242m 3.51E-12( 0.00E+00) 3.24E-11( 2.89E-11) Am243 3.12E-11( 0.00E+00) 2.51E-10( 2.20E-10) Cm242 2.36E-12( 0.00E+00) 1.94E-10( 1.92E-10) Cm243 1.31E-13( 0.00E+00) 8.69E-13( 7.38E-13) Cm244 1.13E-12( 0.00E+00) 1.18E-11( 1.07E-11) ============================================ Average Dif/St.Dv # # # PWR - Th burnup benchmark # ------------------------- PWR THORIUM PIN CELL BURNUP BENCHMARK ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : thburn.lst B(MWd/kgHM) Kinfinity diff(%) ================================================= 0.000 1.23782E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.25755E+00 ( 1.59) 0.114 1.20071E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.21945E+00 ( 1.56) 5.835 1.14828E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.16508E+00 ( 1.46) 10.411 1.12108E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.13705E+00 ( 1.42) 19.563 1.07245E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.08678E+00 ( 1.34) 31.004 1.02014E+00 ( 0.0 ) 1.03097E+00 ( 1.06) 40.156 9.81900E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.90056E-01 ( 0.83) 49.308 9.46360E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.52569E-01 ( 0.66) 51.596 9.38170E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.43716E-01 ( 0.59) 60.749 9.07010E-01 ( 0.0 ) 9.10924E-01 ( 0.43) 72.189 8.73480E-01 ( 0.0 ) 8.76074E-01 ( 0.30) ================================================= Average Dif/St.Dv # PWR THORIUM PIN CELL BURNUP BENCHMARK ================================================= Processed Benchmark analysis reports : 1 case : thburn.lst ISOTOPE AtomDens. diff(%) ================================================= Th-232 1.53769E-02 ( 0.0 ) 1.53805E-02 ( 0.02) Pa-231 1.70440E-06 ( 0.0 ) 1.43595E-06 ( -15.75) Pa-233 1.95229E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.98023E-05 ( 1.43) U -232 1.56006E-06 ( 0.0 ) 1.55672E-06 ( -0.21) U -233 2.74202E-04 ( 0.0 ) 2.66156E-04 ( -2.93) U -234 5.15172E-05 ( 0.0 ) 5.24178E-05 ( 1.75) U -235 1.78104E-04 ( 0.0 ) 1.68101E-04 ( -5.62) U -236 1.39420E-04 ( 0.0 ) 1.39586E-04 ( 0.12) U -238 3.88419E-03 ( 0.0 ) 3.89934E-03 ( 0.39) Np-237 1.82660E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.80642E-05 ( -1.10) Np-239 7.61806E-07 ( 0.0 ) 7.45150E-07 ( -2.19) Pu-238 8.90932E-06 ( 0.0 ) 8.71876E-06 ( -2.14) Pu-239 5.37090E-05 ( 0.0 ) 4.96948E-05 ( -7.47) Pu-240 1.82233E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.80873E-05 ( -0.75) Pu-241 1.90707E-05 ( 0.0 ) 1.82291E-05 ( -4.41) Pu-242 9.96772E-06 ( 0.0 ) 1.03444E-05 ( 3.78) ================================================= Average Dif/St.Dv #