EXFOR Suspicious Data (WPEC SG-30)

Information on this web page is for exclusive use by NRDC centres. The data from this web page should not be quoted or used without the explicit consent of NRDC centres.

Area 1 2 3 4 A B C D E F G J K L M O P R S T V
# of error 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

To be corrected

Data no.CommentError?Source
10238.021pt.2 - ~5 times too large (threshold region)?Dupont I
10772.003~4 times too large. However, this data are more or less consistent with the total (n,2n).?Dupont I
12912.003~4 times too large?Dupont I
13799.002Is this reaction code accurate enough? Data looks like delayed neutron energy spectra (not nubar vs. energy). Moreover, the unit (PC/FIS) does not seem appropriate.Yes?Dupont II

Corrected or no correction required

Data no.CommentError?SourceCorrected inRemark
10074.048likely to be the same issue as in 10074.052 (previously reported)NoDupont II-Raw data from authors
10074.052All flag-3 data are wrong. Flag-1 data are wrong above 401 keV.NoDupont I-Raw data from authors
10298.003~3 times too largeNoDupont II-
10385.004~1000 times too large. The xs unit should be millibarn (not barn).YesDupont ITRANS.1349
10420.002~10 times too large. However, this is consistent with the total inelastic.YesDupont ITRANS.1349
11010.015~10 times too lowNoDupont II-
11265.009~10 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.1349
11274.063~50 times too largeNoDupont I-
11507.081~6 times too largeNoDupont I-
11603.005~20 times too large (DATA-MAX)YesDupont ITRANS.1349
11684.003~1000 times too low (not possible for DATAMAX)?Dupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
11740.021~5 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
11858.015~1000 times too large. The xs unit could be millibarn (not barn). Only few scattered points however.NoDupont I-
11963.002~100 times too large, only few scattered dataNoDupont I-
12033.030~10 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349OUTDT added
12115.002The point at 176 keV is ~3 times too largeNoDupont II-
12168.006The last xs value (at 522 keV) is wrong (~10 times too low)YesDupont ITRANS.1349
12208.003~10 times too large, large uncertaintyNoDupont I-
12558.002~20 times too large in the 10-30 keV rangeNoDupont II-
12583.008DATA-MAX, however the xs unit might be millibarn (not barn)NoDupont ITRANS.1349OUTDT added
12616.003~4 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
12661.002~10 times too largeYesDupont IITRANS.1348
12661.007~10 times too lowYesDupont IITRANS.1348
12912.005The xs data might be given in reverse order?Dupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
13025.002~10 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349COMMENT (by author) added
13033.002~5 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
13042.003~20 times too large. However, this is consistent with the total (n,2n).?Dupont ITRANS.1349OUTDT added
13731.002~2 times too large. This might be CU-CMP (YBa2Cu3O7) not CU-65.YesDupont IITRANS.1348
13731.003likely to be a similar issue as in 13731.002YesDupont IITRANS.1348
13733.004The shape is wrong at low energy. This might be raw data.NoDupont II-
13761.006~10 times too large. The shape is wrong at low energy. This might be raw sapphire (Al2O3) data (not 27Al total xs).YesDupont IITRANS.1349
13761.007~10 times too large. The shape is wrong at low energy. This might be raw sapphire (Al2O3) data (not 27Al total xs).YesDupont IITRANS.1349
13761.008~5 times too large. The shape is wrong at low energy. This might be Si2O3 raw data (not natSi total xs).YesDupont IITRANS.1349
13845.002~100 times too largeNoDupont ITRANS.1349CRITIQUE added
13845.008~2 times too largeNoDupont II-
13846.005The target should be 206Pb (not 207Pb).YesDupont ITRANS.1349
13846.006~10 times too large. The target should be 207Pb (not 206Pb).YesDupont ITRANS.1349
14005.002~5 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.1349
14050.0021.0E+06 times too large (DATA-MAX). The xs unit could be micro-barn (not barn).YesDupont ITRANS.1349
14050.003~50 times too lowYesDupont ITRANS.1349
14118.002~7 times too large. However, this is consistent with the total inelastic (but not partial inelastic)YesDupont ITRANS.1349
20006.003~50 times too low. It seems the integration extends up to a few eV only (below the first resonances).YesDupont ITRANS.2196
20057.002~10 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.2192
20289.006~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
20289.007~10 times too large (b spectroscopy?)NoDupont III-
20341.007~3 times too low... a shift in energy is likely but data might be correct (well... as published)NoDupont I-
20341.018The first point at 3.5 MeV is 2 times largerYesDupont ITRANS.2198One data corrected according to Figure
20418.010The xs value is wrong at 813.55 keV?Dupont ITRANS.2198One data line deleted
20427.002~100 times too low. The unit might be PRT/FIS (not PC/FIS).YesDupont IITRANS.2202
20509.017~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
20523.005~100 times too low. The correction (/1000) applied on 20060313 should be checked.NoDupont I-
20646.006~10 times too large (due to 1/v contribution?).YesDupont ITRANS.2196
20689.006~5 times too largeNoDupont I-
20742.002The xs values are wrong at the following four energies: 4.1443, 4.3149, 17.804, 27.913 MeVYesDupont ITRANS.2196
20748.012~50 times too large (or ~10 times larger than the total (n,alpha) cross section).?Dupont ITRANS.2198COMMENT (should be CRITIQUE?) added
20922.006~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
21288.004~5 times too largeNoDupont I-
21289.002~500 times too lowYesDupont IIITRANS.2204
21322.002~20 times too lowYesDupont ITRANS.2196
21352.011~1000 times too large. The xs unit could be microbarn (not milli-barn).NoDupont I-
21834.011~100 times too large. These might be prompt fission neutrons (not DL).YesDupont IITRANS.2202
21936.009~50 times too large?Dupont ITRANS.2198COMMENT (should be CRITIQUE?) added
21936.018~100 times too large?Dupont ITRANS.2198COMMENT (should be CRITIQUE?) added
22008.002~1000 times too large. The xs unit might be millibarn (not barn).YesDupont ITRANS.2199
22052.003The xs values are wrong at the following four energies: 5.4359, 5.4382, 5.4518, 5.4541 MeV?Dupont ITRANS.2198
22089.0961 point (at 14.69 MeV) is ~10 times too lowYesDupont IIITRANS.2204
22237.002~5 times too largeYesDupont IITRANS.2202
22580.016~5 times too large, large uncertainty howeverNoDupont I-
22637.054The first 2 points (at 13.3 MeV and 13.6 MeV) are completely off. However, they are consistent with the total inelastic cross section.YesDupont ITRANS.2196
23018.007~1000 times too low (already reported by AK)YesDupont IIITRANS.2198
30008.024~4 times too largeNoDupont I-
30008.025~5 times too largeNoDupont I-
30008.031~20 times too largeNoDupont I-
30136.010~10 times too large (b spectroscopy?)NoDupont III-
30136.017~20 times too largeNoDupont I-
30264.033~5 times too large (b spectroscopy?)NoDupont III-
30336.003~5 times too large, large uncertainty howeverNoDupont I-
30403.006~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
30560.003The xs value is wrong at 6 meVYesDupont ITRANS.3127
30577.009~4 times too large. However, this is consistent with the total (n,2n).NoDupont I-
30605.005~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
31178.002~1000 times too low. The xs unit might be kilo-barn (not barn).NoDupont I-
31316.006~10 times too large. However, this is the threshold.NoDupont I-
31410.004~1000 times too large. The xs unit should be microbarn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31412.002~10 times too large (relatively recent data)NoDupont III-
31468.002~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31468.003~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31468.004~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31468.005~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31468.006~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn)YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31468.007~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31520.002The last point (14.7 MeV) is ~10 times too large.YesDupont ITRANS.3127
31538.009~100 times too low. The unit might be PRT/FIS (not PC/FIS).YesDupont IITRANS.3126
31538.010~100 times too low. The unit might be PRT/FIS (not PC/FIS).YesDupont IITRANS.3126
31538.012~100 times too low. The unit might be PRT/FIS (not PC/FIS).YesDupont IITRANS.3126
40227.007~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
40244.004~10 times too large, xs is very low howeverYesDupont ITRANS.4143
40380.003~5 times too largeNoDupont II-
40684.007~10 times too large (Cr2O3 CMP xs?)YesDupont IITRANS.4144
40729.032~3 to 4 times too lowYesDupont IITRANS.4144
41123.009~150 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.4143
41148.010~1000 times too low. The xs unit could be barn (not milli-barn). Moreover, the shape is not correct.YesDupont IITRANS.4144
41500.003~100 times too low. The unit might be PRT/FIS (not PC/FIS).YesDupont IITRANS.4144
A0271.004~10 times too largeNoDupont I-
A0292.002~5 times too large (relatively recent data)NoDupont III-
A0517.020~10 times too large (threshold region)YesDupont ITRANS.A063
A0531.003~2 times too largeNoDupont II-
A1299.002~10 times too largeYesDupont IITRANS.F033
C0271.002The first point (25 MeV) is ~10 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.C087
C0999.002~5 times too low and the shape is not correctNoDupont I-
C0999.004~5 times too lowNoDupont I-
D0046.002~100 times too lowYesDupont ITRANS.D060
D0092.005~100 times too lowYesDupont ITRANS.D060
D0119.004~10 times too lowNoDupont I-
D4018.005~50 times too large (sub-threshold region)YesDupont ITRANS.D060
D4058.032The last point (25 MeV) is ~40 times too largeYesDupont ITRANS.D060
E1890.002~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.E053
E1961.008The energy scale might be wrongNoDupont I-
F0062.003The first point is ~100 times too largeYesDupont IITRANS.F033
F0207.007~20 times too lowNoDupont I-
F0284.003The first 2 points (1-3 MeV) are ~10 times too low and the shape is not correct.NoDupont I-
O0076.015The first point (13 MeV) is ~20 times too large. This is the threshold however.NoDupont I-
O0350.031pt.3 - The shape is not correct (see also T0198.023)YesDupont ITRANS.O036
O1071.002~1000 times too low. The xs unit should be barn (not milli-barn).YesDupont ITRANS.O034
O1118.005~10 times too large. However, this is consistent with the total (a,2n) cross section.No?Dupont ITRANS.O037CRITIQUE added
O1235.007The energy scale might be wrongNoDupont I-
P0019.006~10 times too large (threshold region)NoDupont I-
T0055.002pt.1 - The shape is not correct (wrong target?)YesDupont IIITRANS.C087
T0198.023The shape is not correct (see also O0350.031)YesDupont ITRANS.C087Superseded by O0350