IAEA Benchmark of Spallation Models

IAEA Benchmark of Spallation Models - Calculation Results

This section contains an overall status of the participants, the intercomparison results (both Figures and Data) of experiments to model calculations, and the Figures of Merit (FOM) of this intercomparison. The FOM has been extracted using various numerical/statistical analysis methods and techniques (such as the deviation factors, chi-square values and parameters, ratios of experiment to calculated values) as the indicators for the smooth and advanced ways of treating the results. This method represents a mathematical measure/numerical evidences as additional tools for performing this intercomparison exercise.

[g]: graph, [d]: numerical data, [f]: figure of merits (fom)

Double differential cross section (neutron)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
n	^natFe	65	Hjort	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natFe	800	Amian	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natFe	800	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natFe	1200	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natFe	1600	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natFe	3000	Ishibashi	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	256	Meier	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	800	Amian	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	800	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	1200	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	1600	Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	3000	Ishibashi	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (proton)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
n	²⁰⁹Bi	542	Franz	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	1200	Budzanowski	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Bubak	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁹Bi	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Fortsch	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Goldenbaum	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	800	Chrien	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	800	McGill	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁸¹Ta	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (deuteron)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
n	²⁰⁹Bi	542	Franz	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	1200	Budzanowski	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Bubak	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁹Bi	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Goldenbaum	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁸¹Ta	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (triton)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
n	²⁰⁹Bi	542	Franz	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	1200	Budzanowski	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Bubak	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁹Bi	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Goldenbaum	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁸¹Ta	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (³He)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	¹⁹⁷Au	1200	Budzanowski	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Bubak	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁹Bi	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Goldenbaum	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁸¹Ta	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (α)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	²⁷Al	160	Cowley	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	160	Cowley	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	1200	Budzanowski	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Bubak	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁹⁷Au	2500	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁹Bi	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	62	Bertrand	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natNi	175	Goldenbaum	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	63	Guertin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	¹⁸¹Ta	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (π⁺)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	²⁷Al	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natC	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natCu	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Double differential cross section (π^-)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	²⁷Al	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁷Al	2205	Enyo	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natC	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natCu	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	730	Cochran	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Mass distribution

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	⁵⁶Fe	300	Villagrassa	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	1000	Villagrasa-Napolitani	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	500	Audouin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	1000	Enqvist	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²³⁸U	1000	GSI	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Charge distribution

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	⁵⁶Fe	300	Villagrassa	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	1000	Villagrasa-Napolitani	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	500	Audouin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	1000	Enqvist	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²³⁸U	1000	GSI	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Isotope distribution

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	⁵⁶Fe	300	Villagrassa	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	⁵⁶Fe	1000	Villagrasa-Napolitani	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	500	Audouin	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²⁰⁸Pb	1000	Enqvist	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	²³⁸U	1000	GSI	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Neutron multiplicity distribution

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe	1200	Herbach	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb	1200	Letourneau	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Excitation function (isotopic)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe		Michel+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb		Titarenko+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Excitation function (mass)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe		Michel+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb		Titarenko+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Excitation function (charge)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe		Michel+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb		Titarenko+	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Excitation function (neutron multiplicity En<20 MeV)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe		Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb		Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]

Excitation function (neutron multiplicity En>20 MeV)

Proj.	Targ.	E (MeV)	Author	All	cem 0302	cem 0303	cascade 04	cascade -x	cascade -asf	geant4 -binary	geant4 -bertini	incl45- abla07	incl45- gemin++	incl45- smm	isabel- abla07	isabel- gemini++	isabel -smm	mcnpx-bert-dres	phits-bertini	phits -jam	phits -jqmd
p	^natFe		Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]
p	^natPb		Leray	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]	[g][d][f]